View Full Version : Post-Mortem On Malaysian Loss in INDO Open


X Ball
06-02-2006, 03:40 AM
What do you think ? Good or bad ?

For me, it is another inconsistent display. LCW has failed again. Doubles, ok with our young pair -- good experience.

If it wasn't Hafiz winning the Philippines Open earlier, I would probably call it bad days for Malaysian badminton ahead.:( :(

xijiayu
06-02-2006, 03:48 AM
I hate to say that they have never convinced me most of the time. LCW doesn't play well abroad and has not justified his world number 2 ranking. I am so dissappointed with his lost in IO. Our young doubles are not up to the top 10 standard. I dont see any potential in the other single players like YKB, LTS, JC and YK. My only hope now is to bring up young single players from junior team (which BAM will do) and train them into better players. Our problem in MS is that, we have no realiable MS now (even LCW and HH are inconsistent). China are miles ahead from us and Indo seem doing good with rising Simon. BAM should act quickily or we would not see any good MS playing for MAS for next 5-6 years.

abedeng
06-02-2006, 03:56 AM
BAM need to use more psychological approach. Nothing wrong with the players, just the mind. And it is the mind that determines the champion.

We haven't had players with champion mindset since Razif/Jalani Sidek. They had the correct mental approach, but lost out narrowly in technical ability to Li Yongbo/Tian Bingyi and Park Joo Bong/Kim Moon Soo.

Gaintkiller
06-02-2006, 04:02 AM
The failure this time might be a good sign for Malaysian player in the big tourney coming ahead. Failed in 1 or 2 tourney deosn't mean they are totally collapse. Believe that they will come back in a good shape and raise the Malaysia flag again. Probably in this year world championship......

sickgal
06-02-2006, 05:00 AM
The failure this time might be a good sign for Malaysian player in the big tourney coming ahead. Failed in 1 or 2 tourney deosn't mean they are totally collapse. Believe that they will come back in a good shape and raise the Malaysia flag again. Probably in this year world championship......


totally agree with u!!! i mean why should we to give such a conclusion when they failed to win the Thomas CUp or lose out completely in IO:rolleyes: .....its the nature of a game...either win or lose... when a player lost for eg LCW... i believed he had learned something though...perhaps IO is just another warm up match for him..;) i still think the big deal comes in M'sia Open as he gotta defended the title..:) and plus the fact that in his career he had never reach to final in IO...there should not be cries when he failed to do so..:p not much expectation for him as it would be in M'sia Open...in 2 weeks time..LCW...gam ba te!!! and also to the whole m'sia team...esp MD...hehe..

taufik-ist
06-02-2006, 08:58 AM
totally agree with u!!! i mean why should we to give such a conclusion when they failed to win the Thomas CUp or lose out completely in IO:rolleyes: .....its the nature of a game...either win or lose... when a player lost for eg LCW... i believed he had learned something though...perhaps IO is just another warm up match for him..;) i still think the big deal comes in M'sia Open as he gotta defended the title..:) and plus the fact that in his career he had never reach to final in IO...there should not be cries when he failed to do so..:p not much expectation for him as it would be in M'sia Open...in 2 weeks time..LCW...gam ba te!!! and also to the whole m'sia team...esp MD...hehe..

just incosistent :D

KooGuy
06-02-2006, 09:02 AM
Maybe May'sia can blame the new scoring system. :crying: Who recommend the new scroing system, is it Punch Gunalan? Just kidding....:D

taufik-ist
06-02-2006, 09:08 AM
Maybe May'sia can blame the new scoring system. :crying: Who recommend the new scroing system, is it Punch Gunalan? Just kidding....:D

yes PUCH GUNALAN is the one who insists to use 21 scoring system :D

hara^kazuko
06-02-2006, 09:24 AM
Althought things seem real bad for men singles, but i think malaysia has delivered good men doubles...

I have always believe that chong ming/kean keat may be the next world number one men doubles if they continue they way they are... I see something in them :p probably a hidden star, to be revealed soon...

xijiayu
06-02-2006, 10:51 AM
We have some good MD pairs and I have no worry in MD department. My ultimate worry is from MS where you can find no one after LCW, MHH and KBH. If we want someone to challenge China, Indo and Denmark MS, I bet there are only LCW and MHH (though inconsistent), KBH is not up to standard to beat any top five Chinese players yet. Who else can we think of after these three players (with injured WCH)? LTS, JC, YKB and others currently in national team may even find it difficult to beat Indian and Vietnamese MS. I have mentioned several times in other threads that MAS need potential young players (17-19) urgently. They are now in Rashid's team and were once playing the same junior tournaments with CJ and GWJ from China. CJ is now top 10 in the world and I guess he will become top three within a year. He is like Lin Dan back in 2003. But at least, I am happy that BAM know this problem and will get two single players trained by Li Mao.

sickgal
06-02-2006, 11:02 AM
just incosistent :D

yeah right...:mad: and just wait and see when it comes to international tournaments besides IO.... see how far can the indonesian players go through.......:rolleyes: perhaps they're great at home as there is home crowd and definately the tournament in thomas cup had obviously shown it when their players were not playing at their soil.... would it be another i'nconsistent' as compare to IO when they sailed through to SF???;)

chibe_K
06-02-2006, 11:36 AM
I have been watching the matches where Mal team was playing in TC2006 over and over again and I am actually convinced that Mal players' skills are more superior than other teams (including China and Den ) and more fun to watch. Even though Mal team did not bring home the title, they did create an entertaining show with trick shots and elegant moves. This reminds me of the Brazil soccer team back in the 80s, no world cup title but its definitely the best team.

Here are weaknesses I observe ( BTW, I am just an amateur)

1. Too defensive. KBH, Hafiz, and LCW all have elegant moves that I think even better than LD, or PG. But, they were too defensive and too tense. Like a singer on stage, if the muscles are too tense, the voice is not beautiful. I also think this is the biggest weakness Mal team needs to work on.

2. Stamina. KBH and LCW were more aggressive in the first game and made fewer unforced errors. But after game 1, you could tell its obvious they were gasping all the time.


In short, Mal team needs to play aggressive style and rely more on attacks !

taufik-ist
06-02-2006, 09:09 PM
Here are weaknesses I observe ( BTW, I am just an amateur)

1. Too defensive. KBH, Hafiz, and LCW all have elegant moves that I think even better than LD, or PG. But, they were too defensive and too tense. Like a singer on stage, if the muscles are too tense, the voice is not beautiful. I also think this is the biggest weakness Mal team needs to work on.

2. Stamina. KBH and LCW were more aggressive in the first game and made fewer unforced errors. But after game 1, you could tell its obvious they were gasping all the time.


In short, Mal team needs to play aggressive style and rely more on attacks !

LCW is pure attacking player, he relies on his smashes, if his smashes don't produce points, he will be in trouble.

kokcheng
06-02-2006, 10:11 PM
We have some good MD pairs and I have no worry in MD department. My ultimate worry is from MS where you can find no one after LCW, MHH and KBH. If we want someone to challenge China, Indo and Denmark MS, I bet there are only LCW and MHH (though inconsistent), KBH is not up to standard to beat any top five Chinese players yet. Who else can we think of after these three players (with injured WCH)? LTS, JC, YKB and others currently in national team may even find it difficult to beat Indian and Vietnamese MS. I have mentioned several times in other threads that MAS need potential young players (17-19) urgently. They are now in Rashid's team and were once playing the same junior tournaments with CJ and GWJ from China. CJ is now top 10 in the world and I guess he will become top three within a year. He is like Lin Dan back in 2003. But at least, I am happy that BAM know this problem and will get two single players trained by Li Mao.You are right regarding the singles.Li Mao was in Kedah for the Sukma Games scouting for players from Rashid's squad.He wasn't too happy with their standard at all,according to interview in the chinese press.They lack speed and power.Fitness is also a major concern.Hope they will wake up and do something about it.Seeing young talents from countries like India and Vietnam should jolt them into actions.As for the doubles,hope they keep on improving.

sickgal
06-02-2006, 11:52 PM
LCW is pure attacking player, he relies on his smashes, if his smashes don't produce points, he will be in trouble.

and yet of all the players that the person mentioned about the m'sia players... u only had ur view of LCW..u seemed focused too much of him though,,:p

hara^kazuko
06-03-2006, 05:34 AM
I don't see many of lee chong wei's matches, but he always seems uncertain to me

taufik-ist
06-03-2006, 09:03 AM
and yet of all the players that the person mentioned about the m'sia players... u only had ur view of LCW..u seemed focused too much of him though,,:p

i just want non china player to be # 1, and LCW is the closest one,

the last non china who became # 1 player is taufik hidayat in 2001 :D

sickgal
06-03-2006, 10:57 AM
i just want non china player to be # 1, and LCW is the closest one,

the last non china who became # 1 player is taufik hidayat in 2001 :D

what??did i see this correctly??? 2001????hey..come on..do u live on history???? its 5 years back from now...... if u would count on history....then better keep on stayin in the past.......

as i'd mentioned.... i mean now..there's still none indonesian player in MS in the top 5 from the IBF list...and were u refering to chinese players or players from china??dont tell me u didnt know that LCW is a m'sia player...:p

hara^kazuko
06-03-2006, 01:58 PM
well... it's normal for someone to expect something competative on badminton courts...i don't mean they play boring games.. it's just that when we see our country on court, obviously ur emotions go high.. u gave them high expectations at that time... n the feeling of patriotism is strong at that moment... nothing wrong for giving high expectations n comments bout our national players.. for normal guys like us, we would only want our country to win.. the intention is simple enuff..

Malaysianfan
06-03-2006, 02:10 PM
what??did i see this correctly??? 2001????hey..come on..do u live on history???? its 5 years back from now...... if u would count on history....then better keep on stayin in the past.......

as i'd mentioned.... i mean now..there's still none indonesian player in MS in the top 5 from the IBF list...and were u refering to chinese players or players from china??dont tell me u didnt know that LCW is a m'sia player...:p

I think you have misunderstood taufik ist's statement. He just hopes that LCW could become the world no 1 player and puts an end to China's domination in the no. 1 ranking.

sickgal
06-04-2006, 07:25 AM
perhaps i did.. but only him would understand the most what he meant in his message... but again..if u look at points that each players had collected so far... if LD keeps on winning...there's nothing much to stop them from standing high as world's no. 1...hence...do care less about the rankings and just hope each players will perform their best and deliver a great match for the badminton lovers...

hara^kazuko
06-04-2006, 11:27 AM
well... i assume that we all would be dying to see malaysia on top of the world... i guess nothing debatable... the greatest match would be delivering malaysia a number one...

EastDevil
06-04-2006, 12:03 PM
I personally do not care what nationality the world number one is as long as he is a dedicated professional with good attitude. So Peter Gade, LCW or Lin Dan gets my vote.

Brave_Turtle
06-04-2006, 02:26 PM
I vote for whoever is the most consistant and LD is still in top of the list!

What does attitude has to do with ranking? :confused:

You may find a person nice but the others will find him annoying.

Like other said, MAL team are very skillfull but they are really inconsistent. I hope LCW can improve this side of his game because he's so talented..

smashmouth
06-08-2006, 05:27 AM
I think LCW should stop smoking.

hector_iii
06-08-2006, 07:14 AM
No offense to malaysia fans but ... no matter how much praise u gip dem and how many times u worship dem, simply bcos

hara^kazuko
06-08-2006, 08:13 AM
No offense to malaysia fans but ... no matter how much praise u gip dem and how many times u worship dem, simply bcos

simply because? U haven finish dat sentence yet

hector_iii
06-08-2006, 08:47 AM
the entire BAM structure is disorganized, indiscipline and full of baggage. when u get to compare and see the club system in indon and province team in China; malaysia is juz to provide clown entertainmnt. FYI, malaysia was neber good in badminton. de reason they get to win anythg last time is bcos nobody play badminton yet. but once indon and later china join; malaysia is juz supporting cast. and now even thai, korea can whack malaysian player easily.

hara^kazuko
06-08-2006, 09:04 AM
the entire BAM structure is disorganized, indiscipline and full of baggage. when u get to compare and see the club system in indon and province team in China; malaysia is juz to provide clown entertainmnt. FYI, malaysia was neber good in badminton. de reason they get to win anythg last time is bcos nobody play badminton yet. but once indon and later china join; malaysia is juz supporting cast. and now even thai, korea can whack malaysian player easily.

I guess u just mean men singles or the juniors.. Juniors get whacked when they are inexperienced and our men doubles have been strong..

I dont know anything bout the BAM structure but Malaysian players have been great.. I have not much to complain...

Sephiroth
06-09-2006, 02:10 AM
Well, I was disappointed but LCW does play well abroad i.e. All England 2006 MS -Semi vs Lin Dan. I think he needs to approach his game alittle better, he has enough skill and experience to put most players out of tournaments and then use his focus on harder ones. BTW Chen Yu ... who is he, is he good or a fast learner ?