Thumbs up for Malaysia Line Judges!

[xymaerts]

I really really want to give a thumb up to Malaysia line judge. They are so professional!! No favor on home player at all. They only favor the shuttle head! Perhaps CHN should learn from them and i really hope we can get this kind of "quality " in Beijing Olympic Games. Else is a shame for CHN & is a shame for Chinese all around the world..

[Pemuda]

I really really want to give a thumb up to Malaysia line judge. They are so professional!! No favor on home player at all. They only favor the shuttle head! Perhaps CHN should learn from them and i really hope we can get this kind of "quality " in Beijing Olympic Games. Else is a shame for CHN & is a shame for Chinese all around the world..

I hope we wont go line judge crazy tomorrow should LCW lose.

[vching]

we are not like China :D

[apontoh]

Other countries should set the standard...and hopefully China will follow.

[Louisa]

good....a small country, but with sense of pride n fair play...

[xsakurax]

its remind me to this slogan:"Setinggi mana piala dijulang,tinggi lagi martabat dijunjung"
no matter what our country name and pride is the most important things rather than the medal that we win.. =X

[qwertyu]

I think the malaysian frustration has caused the swing of support for Chinese players to non-CHINESE players after China open 2007's bias line judging. A vanue where previously was second home to the Chinese players due to large ethnic Chinese population here, now turned against the Chinese. (seen in Tine vs ZL game) Chinese has definitely lost more than Championships.

[zqloy]

I think the malaysian frustration has caused the swing of support for Chinese players to non-CHINESE players after China open 2007's bias line judging. A vanue where previously was second home to the Chinese players due to large ethnic Chinese population here, now turned against the Chinese. (seen in Tine vs ZL game) Chinese has definitely lost more than Championships.

Tine's fighting spirit earned the crowd's support. Her performance was just bringing down the house!

[winnie]

I think the malaysian frustration has caused the swing of support for Chinese players to non-CHINESE players after China open 2007's bias line judging. A vanue where previously was second home to the Chinese players due to large ethnic Chinese population here, now turned against the Chinese. (seen in Tine vs ZL game) Chinese has definitely lost more than Championships.
n IMO it's cos of LYB's statement too.. the fans simply found it as too arrogant.. he was so sure that CHN can will all the medals.. as if look down on players from oth countries

[Pemuda]

Tine's fighting spirit earned the crowd's support. Her performance was just bringing down the house!

Spot on!! Fans appreciate hard work and determination.

[d65up2]

Indonesia has good line judges too

[orchiid]

Perhaps CHN should learn from them and i really hope we can get this kind of "quality " in Beijing Olympic Games.
------------------------
well well
Perhaps KOR should learn from them and i really hope we can get this kind of "quality " in next week's match

[george@chongwei]

I really really want to give a thumb up to Malaysia line judge. They are so professional!! No favor on home player at all. They only favor the shuttle head! Perhaps CHN should learn from them and i really hope we can get this kind of "quality " in Beijing Olympic Games. Else is a shame for CHN & is a shame for Chinese all around the world..
if not, why they call it MALAYSIA BOLEH!!!:)

[xymaerts]

I think BWF should have an award by the end of the year to elect out the MOST "cleanest" line judge. And the award is base on Country... This can also acts as and encouragement and perhaps bring up the standard and quality for line judge..What do u all think?

[jimbo]

Kudos to Msia's line judges!!! Big thumbs up to them, as well as service judges. I'm glad to be Msian and SHAME to you, CHEENA's linesmen :rolleyes:

I didnt expect the line judges (during MSF) were so professional and unbiased.

Msia BOLEH....!!!! :D MAJULAH Msia!!!! :p

[Birdwood]

Just wondering if anyone saw 1-3 close calls in MSF, which went against LHI. Could these calls be considered "controversial" and change the outcome if they were wrong :confused:

I agree with xymaerts that Msia line judges did exceptional good job in MO 08 and agree with many of you that Chn should learn from Msia line judges and do "professional and unbiased" jobs in CO and OG.

Msia line judge might have bent the other way around for one or two close calls to favor CY in MSSF game 1. There are always line calls being "too close to call". Unless linesmen bend over to favor other Nations' players every time they see a close call, controversial calls will stay, but we saw very few in MO 08. Indeed, thumb up to Msia line judges :)

[zqloy]

Just wondering if anyone saw 1-3 close calls in MSF, which went against LHI. Could these calls be considered "controversial" and change the outcome if they were wrong :confused:

I agree with xymaerts that Msia line judges did exceptional good job in MO 08 and agree with many of you that Chn should learn from Msia line judges and do "professional and unbiased" jobs in CO and OG.

Msia line judge might have bent the other way around for one or two close calls to favor CY in MSSF game 1. There are always line calls being "too close to call". Unless linesmen bend over to favor other Nations' players every time they see a close call, controversial calls will stay, but we saw very few in MO 08. Indeed, thumb up to Msia line judges :)

Some of them were indeed close, but some sideline shots were out from perspective in tv replays. LHI didnt protest any of it, maybe he knows that too.

[Birdwood]

Some of them were indeed close, but some sideline shots were out from perspective in tv replays. LHI didnt protest any of it, maybe he knows that too.

Thanks, very good point. Personally, I did not think they would change the outcome, but sometimes, they do affect players psychologically.

[zqloy]

Thanks, very good point. Personally, I did not think they would change the outcome, but sometimes, they do affect players psychologically.

There was some strong drift in the stadium, LHI played a good attacking game but was too risky in such conditions. LCW's more cautious strategy to avoid the sidelines was proved to be the victorious.

[Birdwood]

The best MS final seen in a long time, which will sure bring the competition to much higher level this year along with matches in other depts except WD.

[Han]

Some of them were indeed close, but some sideline shots were out from perspective in tv replays. LHI didnt protest any of it, maybe he knows that too.

Human makes mistake, as long as it's not intentional and bias then it's acceptable. Yes, technology is there to minimize the mistake but WBF think it's to costly to implement which is strange. You don't need the one like tennis but at least have few more cameras on side/base lines as stater. Take one small step at a time to eliminate human mistake/bias rather than just claimed not do-able!
Everyone can see the controversy is on the horizon when Olympic comes but not one is taking any action, go figure!

[Birdwood]

Human makes mistake, as long as it's not intentional and bias then it's acceptable. Yes, technology is there to minimize the mistake but WBF think it's to costly to implement which is strange. You don't need the one like tennis but at least have few more cameras on side/base lines as stater. Take one small step at a time to eliminate human mistake/bias rather than just claimed not do-able!
Everyone can see the controversy is on the horizon when Olympic comes but not one is taking any action, go figure!

I agree with you that calls are not perfect and the need for new technology to reduce the problems.

As to intentional or not, sometimes if controversial calls affected match's outcome, even one unintended call can become intentional call in the eyes of many. In those cases, there's no clear cut for the answer :cool:

[Han]

I agree with you that calls are not perfect and the need for new technology to reduce the problems.

As to intentional or not, sometimes if controversial calls affected match's outcome, even one unintended call can become intentional call in the eyes of many. In those cases, there's no clear cut for the answer :cool:

I thought any controversial call in China is intentional by many :D

[Birdwood]

I thought any controversial call in China is intentional by many :D

There were too many of those calls, making them appear to be all intentional. But it could be the results of poorly educated ppl serving as linesmen. Many of them looked to me as unfit for such job and they might have never played sports before, especially baddy (please correct me if I'm wrong), so what do you expect from them: bad line calls big time :cool:

[hcyong]

There was one very obvious line-judging mistake in favour of Gao-Zhao. I guess the linejudge was trying hard to keep awake in a WD match.

[huangkwokhau]

So far Linesmen has done a good job!!

[Winston_T]

I really really want to give a thumb up to Malaysia line judge. They are so professional!! No favor on home player at all. They only favor the shuttle head! Perhaps CHN should learn from them and i really hope we can get this kind of "quality " in Beijing Olympic Games. Else is a shame for CHN & is a shame for Chinese all around the world..


we are not like China :D

it's all about the Beijing Olympics!
LYB and any other parts in Chn try very hard to make sure their players / pairs can qualify into the Olympics. they won't the case of XXZ and XXF will happened again. if u want to blash someone, blash BWF, coz the rule only allow max 3 players / pairs in top 4 to qualify into OG. even the rule is too cruel for Chn, coz previously (OG 04) max 3 in top 8 or top 16 still can qualify. but now, only top 4!

Beijing Olympics is everything for CHN ppl, include LYB, that's why this time they're made so many calls. but only this time (CM & CO 07).
BTW, there is no complaint about the umpires & linejudges during CO 2000 - 2006, and CM 05 & 06.

[Winston_T]

So far Linesmen has done a good job!!

coz it's only an "ordinary match" . let see if local players likes LCW and WMC were involved in "Big Match". would they still fair? that's a big question mark on it.

[Winston_T]

Just wondering if anyone saw 1-3 close calls in MSF, which went against LHI. Could these calls be considered "controversial" and change the outcome if they were wrong :confused:

I agree with xymaerts that Msia line judges did exceptional good job in MO 08 and agree with many of you that Chn should learn from Msia line judges and do "professional and unbiased" jobs in CO and OG.

Msia line judge might have bent the other way around for one or two close calls to favor CY in MSSF game 1. There are always line calls being "too close to call". Unless linesmen bend over to favor other Nations' players every time they see a close call, controversial calls will stay, but we saw very few in MO 08. Indeed, thumb up to Msia line judges :)


Some of them were indeed close, but some sideline shots were out from perspective in tv replays. LHI didnt protest any of it, maybe he knows that too.


Kudos to Msia's line judges!!! Big thumbs up to them, as well as service judges. I'm glad to be Msian and SHAME to you, CHEENA's linesmen :rolleyes:

I didnt expect the line judges (during MSF) were so professional and unbiased.

Msia BOLEH....!!!! :D MAJULAH Msia!!!! :p

at least there are 3 calls favoured to LCW.
don't forget about 2-3 calls against LD during MO 06 finals, that significantly change the outcome.
can this be cathegorized as "fair" umpire & linejudges?:rolleyes:

[ants]

So far MO had a good rating. The only controversial call during MO was the match between PSH vs TH. And it didnt involve any Malaysian player in it.

[Winston_T]

So far MO had a good rating. The only controversial call during MO was the match between PSH vs TH. And it didnt involve any Malaysian player in it.

how about this?


Just wondering if anyone saw 1-3 close calls in MSF, which went against LHI. Could these calls be considered "controversial" and change the outcome if they were wrong :confused:

[Jessica]

it's all about the Beijing Olympics!
LYB and any other parts in Chn try very hard to make sure their players / pairs can qualify into the Olympics. they won't the case of XXZ and XXF will happened again. if u want to blash someone, blash BWF, coz the rule only allow max 3 players / pairs in top 4 to qualify into OG. even the rule is too cruel for Chn, coz previously (OG 04) max 3 in top 8 or top 16 still can qualify. but now, only top 4!

Beijing Olympics is everything for CHN ppl, include LYB, that's why this time they're made so many calls. but only this time (CM & CO 07).
BTW, there is no complaint about the umpires & linejudges during CO 2000 - 2006, and CM 05 & 06.
Can you stop your nonsense here???Thank You...

[block306]

Can you stop your nonsense here???Thank You...

Incredibly so. This guy is quite unbelievable!!

[Winston_T]

yes, CHN was unfair during CO 07. but to tell that CHN always unfair to foreign players was totally unacceptable! can u prove that there was a complaint about the others CHN open since 2000?
if u can prove, then yes, I admire that this is my fault.

[ants]

Who mentioned that CHINA Always unfair in tournaments? I'm going to spank that fella. :D

[Winston_T]

we are not like China :D


its remind me to this slogan:"Setinggi mana piala dijulang,tinggi lagi martabat dijunjung"
no matter what our country name and pride is the most important things rather than the medal that we win.. =X

really sure? forgot about this?


2006 MAS Open Quarterfinals
Peter Gade vs LCW
There was many bad line calls against Gade during the match
Gade did protest against the umpire but TO NOT AVAIL; he just waved his hand and continued the match
He lost the match eventually.

[ronnie14]

omigod.. china is so really, very much, ideed, always unfair in tournaments? aww....somebody pinch me pls! am i dreaming when i read this? :)

[ronnie14]

no offence to d shuttlers but, yah d linesmen in china and korea are awful la.. admit la..

[Winston_T]

no offence to d shuttlers but, yah d linesmen in china and korea are awful la.. admit la..

yes, I admit, CO 07 was unfair for foreign players.
but, MAS linejudging also awful:cool:.

[ronnie14]

yes, I admit, CO 07 was unfair for foreign players.
but, MAS linejudging also awful:cool:.


oh really..oh my...oooooohhh.. winston is soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo right *excitedly

wutever...at least l linejudging in my country is far much better than yours and worth to be proud of, unlike cheeeenaa...