Thread: Past vs Present...
11-16-2009, 11:52 AM #103
11-16-2009, 12:28 PM #104
Last edited by cooler; 11-16-2009 at 12:30 PM.
11-23-2009, 03:42 PM #105
Yang Yang vs. Lin Dan at their peak..
..so, this past weekend, i was out and about playing baddy and getting my behind creamed playing singles...
Afterward, i chatted with this middle age M'sian guy. We were chatting and what do we know, the topic of comparing players of yesteryears and today came to the forefront.
He told me, after watching Lin Dan in his full glory at last yr's Olympics and comparing to what he saw of Yang Yang in the 80s, he'd say both have eerily similar playing style. However, Yang Yang is still superior technically (esp. his x-court shots and fast drop shots) than LinDan. On the other hand, Lin Dan reigns in his stamina, speed and power.
So, I then asked him, "Who does he think will win, between Yang Yang and Lin Dan, both lefties, if both played against each other at their peak age?". He paused for 2.25 seconds and told me "He feels using the old scoring system (15 pts), Yang Yang would kick Lin Dan off the court. However, using the new scoring system, Lin Dan would wipe Yang Yang off the court, simply because Lin Dan is such an offensive-minded player, which suits the current scoring system".
So....there ya go...I'm sure cooler is itching to make a reply..
For those interested in watching Yang Yang in action, here is a video of him in the 1987 World Championships MS Final match vs. Morten Frost:
Last edited by ctjcad; 11-23-2009 at 03:54 PM.
11-25-2009, 07:47 PM #106
Just my fifty cent (tm)
It's hard for me to imagine or compare the both. Frankly i cant see Yang Yang as a super awesome player despite all his titles. ZJH just seems to outshine him.
Yang Yang doesn't really have any 'legendary classic match' where he totally obliterates another 'top class player' unlike both ZJH (joko AE final massacre) and Lin Dan (Olym Beijing 2008, LCW).
11-25-2009, 11:56 PM #107
Do you honestly believe that YY or ZJH have the ability to outmaneuver LD or even LCW?
Do you honestly believe that YY or ZJH have the ability to penetrate LD or LCW defense?
Do you honestly believe that YY or ZJH have the ability to defend from LD's smashes?
PG is smart, but look how he ran out of ideas when faced LCW at this year Hong Kong SS final. TH has good technique, and he got beaten by a half trying LD at France SS final.
I doubt YY or ZJH can do any better than them.
11-26-2009, 01:07 AM #108
the problem with opinion poll (ie, democracy) is that everyone get 1 equal vote, without weighting on individual background knowledge. By their point of view, they are not wrong. Usually from their childhood upbringing and what they remember from old matches as their base of reference. When YY run around alot, sustaining long rallies, usage of lot of different kind of strokes and deception, the middle age M'sian guy believed YY has great skills and that attributed to great tactic and technique. He may not appreciate the long rallies can be due to having 2 equally level players competing or YY can't crush his opponent quickly although YY usually win in the end. From bruce lee teaching. he said, in movies and shows, he uses lots of arms waving, jumping flying kick, roundhouse kick to give great entertainment value and showoff his skills, and fights last a long time, 3 or more minutes. However, in real fights, he said, he doesn't use kicks, just simple basic technique and it should not last more then 0.5 minute. So if LD rip apart his opponent in short duration, most of us don't appreciate his efficiency and didn't see much fancy skills like other players. It's too bad some of us under value speed and power skills. They see real skills as strokes and deception. That is why TH garner so much popularity. He look great against someone lower than him (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7vAhUljTmjU). As the pace cranks up, u get a TH at the 09 French open against LD. Don't get me wrong, i think TH is also very talented but his dropping off in stamina and speed surppressed his other skills
I believe OSS works great for LD as well as he will not waste time and effort to finsh his opponent in 21 point when he can do it in 15 points.
My analogy for that guy who gave his opinion of LD is like this: when he see a skinny guy in public, he view that skinny must be poor because he can't afford food and work alot. lol Of course, i'm just one person opinion as well
Last edited by cooler; 11-26-2009 at 01:18 AM.
11-26-2009, 02:35 AM #109
Again, the opinion is that of someone who had watched & followed Yang Yang & ZJH during their playing career. Further, taking both YY and LD at their peak, he differentiated the scenario as Yang Yang would probably prevail in the old scoring system and LinDan would probably prevail in the new scoring system.
Now, i can imagine, even if he answers all those 3 questions honestly and still keeps the same view, i doubt any Lin Dan fans would accept his opinion.
I'd like to read other BCers' opinions, esp. from those who had followed & watched Zhao Jianhua & Yang Yang (e.g. abedeng, sonnymak, Loh), on their chances vs. LinDan, if they were to play each other in their peak.
..but, i will try to ask him those questions again when i meet him on the baddy court..
11-26-2009, 02:42 AM #110
i grow up watching YY & ZJW at their peak and In my opinion, YY & ZJH at their peak is no match for today top players like LD & LCW.
Better Training, nutrition and equipments helps.
Just like Carl Lewis 9.81second world record in 80s, now Usain Bolt is 9.51second.
ZJH is my idol when growing up but we have to forget about sentimental value when make comparison.
11-26-2009, 02:43 AM #111
How can Yang yang compare to Lin dan , guys look at how Lin dan destroy Lee chong wei at olympics games 08,, it will be the same when Lin dan jump smash ,Yang yang cant do anything abt it
11-26-2009, 04:46 PM #112
YY or ZJH looks sharp in the past only because they were at the top of their era against a lesser opponent. If they are transport to present, I doubt they can look or play nearly as sharp in front of LD/LCW. They would left clueless on the court because they are outclassed in every category, offensive play, defensive play, speed, power and stamina.
11-26-2009, 05:13 PM #113
The questions are good questions, but your examples... PG & TH are way past their primes. Just watch any of their games before 2004 and you will see the big difference in physical ability (for example: can they still follow their smashes as fast as before? The answer is clearly NO; Can they keep their pace like they did 5 years ago? The answer is again a clear NO.).
Except for the LD in OG08 final, I don't think today's best MS is at higher level than the best MS players in 1999. Considering the rumor that ZJH beat SJ easily in a 7-pt game in 1997, I would not answer your questions very quickly...
The point is, if you just "transport" the 1990 ZJH/YY to today, most likely they won't be able to keep up with today's pace; But I believe the situation would change if you allow them some time, say several months, to get used to the badminton game today.
11-26-2009, 05:44 PM #114
if someone could make a huge separation without giving us the specific, i doubt his judgement This huge separation being YY can beat LD in OSS while LD would beat YY in NSS. I just can't fathom the theory that difference in scoring system would change thing around 180 degree.
As an ex.
TH's stamina is a recognized weakness but yet how come the NSS isn't helping him? He has won more and bigger titles under the OSS than NSS. Also in NSS, there is a break at 11 point too.
11-26-2009, 05:57 PM #115
Last edited by cooler; 11-26-2009 at 06:04 PM.
11-27-2009, 04:06 AM #116
Dear cooler (BC's LinDan's die-hard & numero uno supporter)..
- Yes, my M'sian friend also brought up the example of TH. TH, to him, is technically better than LD. However, Taufik is not an offensive/attack oriented player like LD. Taufik at his peak & playing with the OSS, in the 2004 OG & 2005 WC, are proof enough of his prowess. The scoring system doesn't really affect much with a player's fitness (stamina). But it does affect the style of a particular player.
Anyone else who witnessed Yang Yang and ZJH play in the 80s, other than SibugiChai, wants to chime in??..
Last edited by ctjcad; 11-27-2009 at 04:20 AM.
11-27-2009, 02:39 PM #117
11-27-2009, 05:08 PM #118
Guess what I found.
Some dude from the USA beat Ardy Wiranata in a local tournament. Although Ardy is already in his 40s but I am surprise he got beaten by a causal player with all his skills from the PAST...
Consider he was a world class player back then along with Yang Yang and ZJH..... perhaps he hasn't played any badminton for the past 20 years??? Maybe ye333 could give us some insight.
11-27-2009, 05:43 PM #119
By allyjack110 in forum Badminton Rackets / EquipmentReplies: 35: 05-29-2011, 03:40 AM
By bad_fanatic in forum Badminton Rackets / EquipmentReplies: 8: 12-23-2008, 03:17 PM
By Cheung in forum Professional PlayersReplies: 25: 10-16-2007, 10:12 PM
By demolidor in forum Badminton Tournament Video SharingReplies: 4: 01-18-2006, 09:15 AM
By V1lau in forum Professional PlayersReplies: 1: 04-17-2005, 08:47 PM