Results 1 to 17 of 29
05-27-2012, 06:44 AM #1
Li Yong Bo dares to critize others that follow his mastery of WalkOver tactics
05-27-2012, 11:43 AM #2
"...Although China, with the largest number of players on the circuit, are more likely than other nations to meet compatriots in matches, complaints have been filed with the Badminton World Federation (BWF).
In response, the BWF promised to record all matches from the quarter-finals stage onwards to look into irregularities and suspect retirements.
If compelling evidence is found of any irregularities, the matter will be treated with the utmost gravity by the BWF and severe penalties will be imposed, a statement last year said.
So far no further action has been taken.
Does it have to be that obvious and blunt....LOL
05-29-2012, 05:31 AM #3
LYB is missing the point.
There is very little strategic (if any) value for anyone in purposely withdrawing / retiring against players from another team.
But a lot of potential value for the team in doing the same when two players / pairs of the team meet each other.
So, the following quote from the article is the crux of the matter:
"The study found that just over 20 percent of matches between Chinese players were not completed. But when Chinese shuttlers met other nations, the number of retirements and walkovers plummeted to 0.74 percent."
Although we know it to be true but we never had the numbers. Now we have the numbers that show (if the numbers are accurate) significant discrepancy. Chinese shuttlers tend to give walkovers / retirements roughly 20% more when meeting own teammates than when meeting other players.
05-29-2012, 08:29 AM #4
"Why, when both Indonesian women’s singles withdraw in one tie and also Lee (Chong Wei), there is no attention on that? Three in one day and nothing,” said Li after his women’s team qualified for the Uber Cup final in Wuhan this week" . . . quote Li Yong Bo
I just wonder if it is fair for LYB to include Lee Chong Wei. Everyone with eyes can see that LCW is injured in court, all except LYB. LYB is really an axxhxxx
05-29-2012, 09:17 AM #5
The point is the 2 withdrawn through injuries were fit enough to play again within 24 hours.
So bold that if LYB not dire to try.
And what BwF did about that, absolutely nothing
05-29-2012, 09:28 AM #6
KOREA did some creative pairing a few years ago and forced BwF to change the rule.
INDONESIA probably forced BwF to change the rule again,
you just can't have someone withdrawn from injuries and back the next day.
One solution is for any injuries there is a mandatory 4 weeks resting/recovery period, say.
You are not allow to play again within the 4 weeks period.
05-29-2012, 10:57 AM #7
But if the Chinese were to do that,they would be booed and lambasted for cowardice,lacking in fighting spirit,irresponsibility,being disgraceful,shameful and be called all sorts of names - clearly a case of double standards and hypocrisy.
For those who are quick to jump on China but not their own kind would do well to bear in mind the age-old Confucian adage:"Do not do to others what you do not want done to yourself". And hypocrites ought to know,when you say a thing is wrong when others do it,it is also wrong when you do it.
Yes,make it mandatory that those who cite injury as the reason for withdrawal or retirement should be banned for the rest of the tournament at least.
05-29-2012, 11:34 AM #8
the retirement of ina's WS players seems to be part of strategy, they maybe want to save more energy to face another team in QF than fighting with china team who tend to win 5-0 over them. and if that's the case, i think the word cowardice,lacking in fighting spirit,irresponsibility,being disgraceful,shameful (quoted from Justin L.'s) are appropriate on them too as to the chinese.
about LCW, i don't know why LYB mention him too. btw, how is his condition right now?
MHHung liked this post
05-30-2012, 03:34 AM #9
To point out similar behaviour by other teams, you need to dig hard to find incidences done by KOR some years ago, for example. Or even bring out fake examples like LCW retiring, because there are just not enough evidence to pile up.
It is disingenuous to equate what CHN does with what other teams do, just when some other team show one or two instances of the same, as if it somehow vindicates CHN.
craigandy liked this post
05-30-2012, 04:23 AM #10
Aiyah, normal lah, rules can be manipulated but cannot be broken. In game, business or life, this how things work. But compare to other players, China players like Lin Dan previously with low sportsmanship compare to Lee, Taufik or Bonsak.
Also most China players are chickens, not dare to play as many tournaments as possible. LCW is the best for participating most of the super series and he deserve to pocket all the price money
But anyway, lately Lin Dan have been improving his sportsmanship by giving/exchanging souvenirs with his opponent in a match. Perhaps he's getting to know there're more then just winning in games.
05-30-2012, 04:30 AM #11
Jung/Kim and Shon Wan Ho - got some of the points they needed through walkover wins over compatriots in 2011. As is always the case with walkovers, you can argue that they would have won anyway but it is obvious from hindsight in these cases that since they barely got enough points to qualify, they wouldn't have done so if not for those wins.
05-30-2012, 05:02 AM #12
What la you Oldman LYB
Even though he didnt see LCW get injured, Im pretty sure he cant miss the news of LCW's injury the next day, especially the pics where LCW grimaced in pain, and CRIED, even wheeled out of the tourney. All these not enough credentials to prove LCW didnt fake retirement?? Should LCW email his ankle scan to him?
bad's fan liked this post
05-30-2012, 05:27 AM #13
Conceding a walkover without lifting a shuttle for whatever reason,faked injury or not, is more clear-cut - he or she is out of the tournament for good. China did that mainly to their compatriots - Lin Dan retiring towards the end of G2 vs K Tago and recently Chen Jin giving walkover to P Kashyap are rare exceptions and their respective beneficiaries weren't complaining. In what way "China does it consistently"?
As for "match-fixing",a different subject,my stand is more or less similar to Indian coach P Gopichand's , resignedly speaking - I often chided them for not playing or fighting it out. http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/s...w/12914047.cms
The two issues aren't exactly the same,don't confuse them. Btw, Lindaweni's injury retirement actually adversely affected Wang Shixian who wasn't given a chance to prove she could decisively beat her opponent,much to her detriment.
05-30-2012, 06:06 AM #14
The above presumably LYB's exact words. Ask any lawyer,he/she would probably say " What does he mean by that? What is "nothing"? He will have to explain himself,there is too little to go by;otherwise if I were to accuse him of anything wrong in court, I may not have a strong case."
Don't assume I'm speaking up for him. Of course,LYB is not blind or stupid as not to know Lee CW's injury as you've painstakingly pointed out. I guess he's referring to all the criticisms levelled at him whenever any of his players retired,injured(real or faked) or withdrawn. Don't be too quick to jump to conclusions without ascertaining all the facts,his exact words or read too much into it. That's the difference between objectivity and subjectivity. I rest my case.
05-31-2012, 05:59 AM #15
But I'd just want to point out another big difference. The pull-outs by the Indonesians in the Uber Cup (though still something we should not approve of) is akin to conceding the rubber game after losing both opening games. The team has already lost. It is not match-fixing when the result is already determined. Whereas doing the same in individual tournaments, those are clearly match-fixing. And LYB is trying to equate those two and vindicate himself.
05-31-2012, 06:02 AM #16
05-31-2012, 06:16 AM #17
It takes two to tango if you only get 1 player in the draw, can't do much about that, can you?
LYB stated so many times that he is not interested for his players play against each other, its kind of pointless as far as his concern.
crashdemon liked this post
By twobeer in forum Rules / Tournament Regulation / OfficiatingReplies: 22: 12-06-2011, 04:32 PM
By xymaerts in forum Malaysia Open / Korea Open 2011Replies: 368: 01-30-2011, 11:46 PM
By loweechng in forum China Open (1) / Macau Open / New Zealand Open 2008Replies: 2: 10-03-2008, 10:18 AM
By smash in forum China Open (1) / Macau Open / New Zealand Open 2008Replies: 4: 09-27-2008, 12:01 PM
By weeyet in forum World Championships 2006Replies: 57: 09-22-2006, 07:10 AM