View Poll Results: who's to be blamed for the match throwing?
- 215. You may not vote on this poll
The players are at fault for throw matches
BWF is to blame for implementing group structure
no one / other are to be blamed.
both players and BWF are to be blamed
08-01-2012, 07:42 PM #69
08-01-2012, 07:49 PM #70
Apparently, in their final group game, the Japanese women's soccer team also manipulated the result to purposely finish second in their group:
Here's a direct quote from a player:
“It was the coach’s instruction that we wanted to stay in Cardiff and come second in the group,” said Japan’s Azusa Iwashimizu. “So it was difficult to play, but I understood his idea because it is something we needed to do in order to get a medal.”
08-01-2012, 08:04 PM #71
1. It's soccer, who can tell one 90 min period of boredom from one contrived 90 min period of boredom.
2. There is a long and proud tradition in soccer of 'playing not to lose' rather than playing to win. Often resulting in 90 mins of 'keep away'.
3. Soccer is the most popular game on the planet. It's unlikely that the actions of the Japanese (women's team no less) is going to have much effect on the popularity or image of soccer as a sport.
4. It's the Japan's women's team. For a badminton analog imagine Canada throwing a doubles match to Australia. Can't really see much of a stir resulting. Now imagine Brazil and Argentina fixing a soccer match in the Olympics.
5. For this to be even a parallel to what happened in Badminton you would need to have seen Japan upon scoring a goal follow up equalizing by kicking the ball into their own goal. At least the Japanese managed to under perform without making a mockery of the game.
6. Who cares about soccer. I could probably dredge up better examples of poor sportsmanship/cheating in Olympic history. Would me doing so excuse the actions of the WD players? Is anything ok as long as you can sight a worse example?
08-01-2012, 08:17 PM #72
I can surely agree with you on that part. But then you'd also have to add:
Every format/system/rule you set out is now your responsibility to enforce or see that the rule is not stupid, and applicable. You are answerable. You live by the sword, you die by the sword. You made the format change (even though it hasn't ever been used in Olympics, and there was no need to change), you should be punished as well. If you let the coaches walk, I can understand if the President can scapegoat the ones who come up with the idea. But blaming coaches for direct orders etc. Okay sure. President of BWF signed off on all major decisions right? Therefore, President of BWF MUST resign after this. Changes must be made right?
08-01-2012, 08:20 PM #73
Nothing about anything was right. The only real lesson I learned here is that you can still tank or not try. You just can't be THAT obvious about it. Or if you are going to make such a ruling, you must set out effort level, how MUCH do you have to try, and scope it over all the events and tournaments. I'm looking at you Taufik and all the high level players. No more backhands and having fun! You have to TRY!
08-01-2012, 08:33 PM #74
for those who think the round robin system is the problem which caused the foul play
this is like blaming people for too rich to get robbed or blaming people for too pretty to be raped.
08-01-2012, 08:34 PM #75
I am an observer and see these news. It's a real shame on badminton. Especially the top executive.
Please support your own country to try their best whenever they play. Walkovers and giving points away is very unprofessional. Image tarnished.
Who is this Lund guy? Shame on him. Shame on China for being the first culprit to initiate this also.
08-01-2012, 08:40 PM #76
International Soccer, like the World Cup, will play the pool games at the same time so you won't know for sure who you play if you win or lose, so that this doesn't happen. It happend with Germany and someone before where both teams got who they wanted with a tie and they did play keep away for 90 minutes. Everyone said that was real bad and from then on they played at the same time from then on.
On ESPN Radio today SVP said it that losing on purpose was a smart move to play weaker players in the next round. If your goal is to advance, it is difficult to argue against.
Winning should always give you a better chance to advance. If a lot of players lookat at it different, whomever set it up should be to blame not the players.
08-01-2012, 08:53 PM #77
It is like, right before the NBA Playoffs (to a lesser extent soccer, statistically upsets are higher, luck plays its hand a bit more) some teams lose to get better seeding or purposely lose to avoid more dangerous teams thereby effectively paving an easier on the way.
The whole thing must be restructured.
Last edited by King's; 08-01-2012 at 09:01 PM.
08-01-2012, 09:00 PM #78
Those who put the blame squarely on BWF are missing the point. Whatever system you put in place there would always be people who cheat and try to beat the system. The problem is not the system or format but lack of integrity and ultra nationalism of the cheaters.
Instead of condemning the cheaters, players, coaches and national associations we are condemning the watchers.
These cheaters have no love for badminton.
I am glad the IOC have come out hard on these cheats. BRAVO!!!!!!
08-01-2012, 09:04 PM #79
Someone once said that in order to be the best, you must defeat the best. It is no point one strategies to meet easy opponent in the earlier rounds, if you are the best in the world you will beat any opponent tough or easy long the way.
08-01-2012, 09:27 PM #80
It's sad that probably BWF will get away with this by solely blaming the players. I read somewhere that they even got praised by IOC for being strict...
08-01-2012, 09:30 PM #81
we cannot satisfy the best of both world...now those siding their fav players and country will say BWF and IOC are liable for coming out with this "stupid" grouping system...hence allowing room for manipulating....like some already openly admit that they took advantage out of it.... but if BWF and IOC use knockout stage from the beginning, some might not happy when they get knocked out in the 1st RD.. just take an example, if YY/WXL "unfortunately" lost to pair from RUS in the 1st RD, that's it ..bye-bye to them.....can any of the players whinned about how hard they trained for the past and get knockout by one worst performance and no second chance for them??
BWF and IOC set the rules....right or wrong, the players should at least try their best .....they are bound by the rules....once you entered, you must follow and dont complain later
08-01-2012, 09:34 PM #82
To put things into perspective, most voters are voicing out for both players and BWF to change. No use just having one party solely to be blamed. If you truly want change for the betterment of badminton, then why not both parties go hand in hand? True, the players themselves are at fault, but majority of votes here are not just saying BWF is the one and only 'ENABLER' (for lack of a better term). Majority says both are at fault. Both. So those who say players are at fault, correct. But to say BWF has nothing to do with it? Pls,. After this, I should say, there will be some pressure on BWF whether to continue with round robin. Even if they decide not to do away with round robin, there will be pressure. And that says the role and responsibility that BWF carries. So stop putting the fault on just ONE(1) party alone. Everyone has a role to play.
It should be noted that the round robin was implemented because of a major reason to have the weaker countries have more participation and not feel left out by always being whitewashed. I guess, the good intention led to a bigger devil.
While the outright DQ is what I champion for, the hope for format restructuring should be on the horizon soon. If you think DQ alone is sufficient enough to remediate and cure, think again. DQ though brings the cane to the buttocks, it also causes embarrassment and unwanted negative attention to the sport, as mentioned by plenty!
Last edited by Pakito; 08-01-2012 at 09:49 PM.
08-01-2012, 09:35 PM #83
08-01-2012, 09:40 PM #84
A more suitable analogy would be:
Students are cheating because they are encourage to do so (no punishment whatsoever for cheater). If a student is not very bright and doesn't cheat, they will not be accepted at certain school/university because other students which also are not very bright are cheating as well. Are they innocent? No. However, they are not the only one that can be blamed.
xXazn_romeoXx liked this post
08-01-2012, 10:14 PM #85
This is really very bad publicity for badminton.
BWF fought so hard to get it played as an official Olympic Sport event, and this super negative publicity has to happen.
The whole world watches this grand 'once every 4 years' event, and the Best all aspires to play in the Olympics, and the playing of these 4 pairs really destroyed years of hard work in 1 day.
Badminton is fighting hard to get 'big' sponsors from Europe and USA, and the London Olympic is one of the best avenue to showcase what badminton has to offer, I guess now with this catastropic happening, it may have the reverse effect.