Results 1 to 13 of 13
11-26-2012, 06:47 AM #1
Suggestion: Stop New Members Selling on BC!
Stop New Members Selling on BC!
I know the title may sound harsh to some but the intention is to protect buyers.
Having been using the forum for a number of years now, I have seen a lot of fake racquets being sold on the forum. Sometimes these may be from unsuspecting members who were unaware that they were fake but more often, these seem to be from those who are intentionally deluding others by selling fakes.
I appreciate that it is the responsibility of the buyer to check the authenticity of the racquets before buying and BC has no affliation with the sale, however I feel that this is not always fully possible, and as a forum more can be done to help the buyers.
There are countless instances where new members have signed up to BC, with zero post counts, purely to sell racquets and I have seen a significant number of these which I would personally deem as fakes.
I feel that by allowing anyone to just come on here, with no post counts, history, feedback or forum credibility to sell items is very risky. There used to be a time when fakes were easy to spot, but nowadays even armed with serial codes we cannot be 100% sure. Photos may not be of the actual item, and fakes can be very difficult to spot.
I know the forum cannot be responsible for irradicating illegitimate sales, but I feel the forum can help to reduce this risk for buyers and to help deter these scammers.
- Prevent members with post counts less than a certain number from posting in the buy/sell forum. This number can be determined between the admin staff. I would suggest something in the order of 100 "credible" posts. A lot of other forums I use have this in place as it deters scammers from selling. It also gives some sort of insight/history of the member.
- Seller feedback ratings. This can help buyers decide the trustworthiness of the seller.
- Sale/Seller Testimonials. This can be captured in a single thread whereby buyers can simply write a short note in a pre-determined format (like the fake racquet identification format) about the sale which would allow for easy searching for future potential buyers.
- Photos of the actual item for sale to have a written note stating the member username and date photographed with the actual item. This goes some way to prevent scammers from taking photos off the internet and passing them off as their own.
I hope the BC admin will give this some consideration
11-26-2012, 10:37 AM #2
I have bought and sold stuff on this buy/sell forum. My rule of thumb is to look at the post count. If it's less than 10...chances are they aren't real badminton fans and are just wanting to make a quick buck. And I look at when they joined (ie. joining same month and selling same month) and their post history.
If I'm really suspicious...I ask for a photo of the racket with a newspaper current date. If they can't even do that...no deal. It proves that the seller actually has the racket.
11-26-2012, 11:43 AM #3
11-29-2012, 05:19 AM #4
Totally agree, 100 posts are sufficient enough.
12-03-2012, 10:35 PM #5
what!! 100 posts... .....................
i spend more of my time here buying than selling though..
12-04-2012, 05:52 AM #6
As you have pointed out, like most of us, you spend more time here buying than selling. So it probably isn't a hugely inconvenient for you. If new members wanted to sell there are various other options they can use.
I personally think the forum should be used first and foremost for discussions and reference, with the buying/selling section as a bonus secondary feature. With that in mind, surely by allowing members with zero post counts to sell on BC without intending to contribute to the forum is just taking advantage of the freedom that the forum offers.
To me this just seems like a loop-hole that needs to be tightened for the better of the forum and its members.
I'm surprised that not a single moderator has commented on this, despite the interest from members but deciding to "sticky" another related but unhelpful thread.
12-05-2012, 01:33 AM #7
I have proposed the post count limit and yet getting feedback from admin quite some time ago.
so far, we are quite lenient towards BC members. we are all sportsman and sportswoman. yet, there is still a small number of members mis-use the buy/sell thread. few created multiple usenames just to do selling. some registered as member just for selling.
badmintoncentral always a place(forum) for badminton lovers share their views. buy/sell section is just a place helping members trade off their used badminton items.
we will further discuss on this matter and for the time being, we will monitor as it goes.
12-05-2012, 04:50 AM #8
I note that BC has been quite relaxed towards such members who abuse the buy/sell forum to date, but having noticed over the years what appears to be a growing trend I think it is time BC clamped down on these members who think they're making a fool out of us and mocking the good nature of the forum. (I sympathise with the "identifying fake racquet gurus" who must have been working flat out over the years! )
I hope other moderators will consider this favorably too and instigate some house rules in the buy/sell forum.
12-05-2012, 07:21 AM #9
rest assure that we are keeping eyes on buy/sell section.
for your info, there are many threads being deleted. some are issued with warning. as for multi usernames, they are banned.
some just slipped through our fingers as we are not able to keep track everyone.
a report will enable us act faster, just click (!) sign.
12-07-2012, 12:17 AM #10
My suggestion is to close the *buy and sell* forum as it seems to create more problems than it solves.
I would have hoped buyers show a more alertness when buying second hand items instead of blaming moderators. I always remind people *caveat emptor* principle. Perhaps badminton second hand buyers are a more gullible population?
For us as moderators, we have to be impartial and you know it's not an easy task most of the time.
12-07-2012, 02:54 AM #11
the buy/sell section is extremely helpful for people to look for racquets that suit that play though.. there's no where else on the internet where this is carried out so well unlike at BC.
and its usually the nubs (me included), that need to cycle through more racquets due to age, due to poor strength that cannot be improved too much before injury sets in etc..
if possible, i definitely wouldnt mind to pay for listing things for sale or paying to buy off BC, maybe a few dollars per post, to allow the cost to go into hosting of BC, and some to go towards someone in the trade able to check and match serial numbers
a strong disclaimer is necessary too, to let the platform stay, and allow BC moderators to be non-liable for all trades that are carried out.
you'll never know the joys of me buying a z-slash or a ns9900, recently after using a mp99-at900t in tandem for the past six-seven years.. and BC allowing me to save $90 and $60 respectively for the toys..
12-07-2012, 04:23 AM #12
It depends also on your goals for BC, I suppose. If you see BC as a place mainly for discussions, etc., and you want to limit buying/selling, then go ahead. But if you want BC to be a virtual reflection of the "real world" badminton ecosystem, then you must allow maximum freedom and tolerate the bad with the good (but also can get rid of the extremely bad, ha ha).
One way forward could be having an exclusive "commercial section" subforum in the buy/sell forum where people who just want to trade without discussing can go about their business, and the rest can go on with theirs.
Just my half pence worth
12-07-2012, 08:38 AM #13
I'm not suggesting that my proposals above are a sure-fix, but it's a start. I personally believe that by imposing some new rules/features to the buy and sell forum will make a significant positive change to the forum. I've seen similar rules applied in other site forums with good results so I can only imagine this will contribute to improving BCF in the long run and hopefully be welcomed by its members.
Sometimes, showing alertness is not always enough. If people are determined enough to scam buyers, they will find ways to do it. Just as a determined hacker will get into any computer system. Yes, the buyer has responsibility for satisfying themselves that the sale is genuine etc, but if the facilities are not there to help them make that decision better, there is not a lot for them to go by.
At the end of the day, the "fault" here is not with the buyer, the fault is with the scammer.