Results 1 to 17 of 24
Thread: Collision accident
06-22-2005, 06:17 PM #1
I was playing doubles, covering the front court while my partner was in the rear court. While trying to return a shuttle with my head turning sideways, all of a sudden my partner's racket hit my right eye at full force. The lens shattered. I was bleeding and saw only a blur for the next 10 min or so. My partner immediately commented: "he was in my lane". Could he be correct? He was playng behind me and could see my movements at all times, whereas playing in front of him, I could not see him. The fact that he rushed forward to me, does this not seem to indicate that the shuttle was closer to me than to him? I was transported by ambulance to a hospital ER where the ER doctor pronounced me extremely lucky with only a cut in my eyeball but otherwise no internal damage. I am posting this because my aggresive partner maintains it was my own fault; he has offered no apology. What I wish to know from fellow BFers is this: 1)when you play doubles, do you defend lanes, or the entire width of either the front-, or rear court?; 2)is your partner not supposed to give you enough playing room?
PS. Three players who witnessed the accident told me that my partner has a reputation of being a "dangerous" player who was involved in other collisions before.
06-22-2005, 06:24 PM #2
Your partner is at fault, as he has clear field of view of what's happening in front of him.
Count yourself extremely lucky, and good luck in a speedy recovery.
06-22-2005, 06:29 PM #3Originally Posted by cocotte
06-22-2005, 06:34 PM #4Originally Posted by cocotte
My take on this is that it doesn't matter who's shot it is. The player in the back can easily see where his partner is and should never be swinging with any force when there is a chance that he may hit his partner backing up.
06-22-2005, 06:52 PM #5
it sounds like he's a bit careless, but basically it's both and neither of your faults simply because:
a) neither of you called for it and you hadn't discussed how you were going to play.
defending lanes as you quite descriptively put it is a basic strategy altho leave your side struggling to maintain the attack when your opponent simply blocks to the net in front of you after a smash from the back.
front and back play on it's own doesn't work either because the player at the back will get tired eventually from the harder hitting required.
so both strategy's are employed in a game. unless you or your partner doesn't grasp the idea of rotating between to two strategy's.
in the end i think the blame is mostly on him. he can see you, but you can't see him. i certainly wouldn't continue with my swing full power if i could see my partner was going for the same shot. or i would at least shout mine if i saw you heading for it.
for future reference either don't play with him, or politely ask him how he would like to play, (and not to clobber you if he can see you going for what he thinks is his shot)
hope this helps
06-22-2005, 07:24 PM #6
I think it depends on what level your partner is at. I doubt if a beginner can see you alll the time while concentrating at hitting the bird. But no matter whose fault it is, he hit someone at the eyes and should always apologize. This guy is too rude.
06-22-2005, 07:36 PM #7
I'm with Qidong. Regardless of whose shot it really was, you smack or hurt someone, you apologise. Especially when it's bad enough to put him in a hospital.
IMHO, he's not at fault for going for the shuttle or even for hitting you. He's at fault for failing to apologise.
06-22-2005, 08:54 PM #8
I wont hit a shuttle if there is a risk of injury. Its just not worth it. My partners feel the same way, or else I wouldnt play with them.
06-22-2005, 09:31 PM #9Originally Posted by cocotte
06-22-2005, 09:54 PM #10
CollisionOriginally Posted by merlin
Thank you all fellow BFers for your reassuring comments. This accident is a good lesson for me as a 76-year old. In the future, I'll be more careful in choosing a doubles partner. Yes, I consider myself extremely lucky with the good prognosis of my eye.
06-23-2005, 12:30 AM #11Originally Posted by Qidong
Reardless who's fault is, if someone is bleeding, there's no time or should ever thinking about finger pointing. More likely, ur partner might be scared of the incident, and trying to push off responsibility.
Therefore, no matter what kinda skill lvl he is, I will get myself another partner. No responsibility and no sportsmanship will always piss me off.
06-23-2005, 04:56 AM #12
It's never worth risking an injury. If there is danger of hitting your partner, you should always let the shot go.
The rearcourt player must accommodate the front player's movement, even if it is mistaken. The front court player should avoid turning round during a rally.
If a player has a casual attitude towards causing such injuries, then you should refuse to play with him. It might be a bit socially awkward to say that, but your health and safety is more important. Besides, players EARN the right to play with a partner; it can be lost if they behave badly.
06-23-2005, 05:00 AM #13
Speedy recovery, man! Totally agree with others here, your partner is not worth the trouble of lecture if he is so narrow focus as to totally ignore your presence during a DOUBLES game. His action reveals alot about his character and calibre. Save your trouble and others' by letting them know what really happened so that they could decide whether they should play with him next time. I find social ostracization to be a doubly effective means of correcting bad behaviours or ridding of bad elements.
His lame excuse of you being in his 'defending lane' doesn't hold water as you wouldn't have intercept the shot had it been a defensive situation. Sounds like he's one of those "I play my side and you play yours" player. Either those kinds of players are ignorant of doubles rotation strategy (I would give them a break) or they prefer to play singles on a half court area (I would avoid them like the plague).
06-23-2005, 05:09 AM #14Originally Posted by ryeung
But I think not apologizing is a very poor form I hope you have a speedy recovery cocotte
06-23-2005, 06:28 AM #15
get well soon mate!! hmmm.. dun worry.. he will reap wat he sow.. he will receive the same treatment next time.. haha.. there are sure more worthy partners for you out there.. Cheers :>
06-24-2005, 10:02 PM #16Originally Posted by coops241180
In a normal doubles game, after I serve, I usually protect the front court. When my partner serves, I stand behind him/her, and then protect the rear court. So no partner stays at the rear all the time; we alternate during a game. Thanks for your wishes. My cut eye is healing!
06-25-2005, 01:29 AM #17
I too have a case of collision with my partner during a double game. This time, my partner was at the front. The shot from our opponent flew toward the back of our court and I was guarding the back. My partner who was a beginner in this game just swing his racket and hit me right on my head!!! He didnt even noticed I was right behind him. Wow, I got a mini volcano on my head. Just squated down and rubbed my head as hard as possible to subdue the pain. From that day onward,
I just avoid partnering this guy. Too dangerous to play with him.In future game, I just give way to my partner if I find him too earger to take the shot.Better to be safe than get injured.
Originally Posted by cocotte
By thumpsky in forum General ForumReplies: 29: 04-04-2012, 06:59 PM
By toomanyracquets in forum Badminton Stringing Techniques & ToolsReplies: 7: 04-03-2012, 11:16 AM
By ants in forum Malaysia Professional PlayersReplies: 64: 10-18-2007, 09:40 AM
By Pete LSD in forum General ForumReplies: 26: 05-12-2005, 09:03 PM
By ants in forum Singapore Open 2004Replies: 0: 11-17-2004, 09:09 PM