Thread: Rudy Hartono
08-10-2012, 12:41 PM #35
08-10-2012, 01:16 PM #36
But if Jesse Owen were alive today, he might be able to run less than 9 seconds because he has to compete with Usain Bolt who is very fast.
08-10-2012, 03:49 PM #37
With the circumstances in each own times, past champions like Wong Peng Soon, Eddy Choong, Erland Kops, and Rudy Hartono had same disadvantage in terms of technology, tools, knowledge, nutrition and everything else with any others players at their own time, but they did more and more than anyone to claimed their tittles and be the champion of their own era. So I don't think anyone in this forum has an excuse to turn down and discredit they achievements.
what a shame
08-10-2012, 11:29 PM #38
08-11-2012, 01:24 PM #39
In short Rudy Hartono won those titles in the absence of Chinese players, the era when the badminton standard is so poor that it is comparable to school level today, and the fact very few players around him were able to play proper badminton.
That is so prehistorical achievement.
08-11-2012, 02:59 PM #40
No one say that such a "prehistorical" things except a few of negative and disgrace members of this forum.
08-11-2012, 03:10 PM #41
Maybe one day when a new country emerge to be the powerhouse of badminton then they will look back and say that our present days is a prehistorical era because they not there already and discredit all the achievements of Lin Dan, Lee Chong Wei, Taufik Hidayat, Peter Gade, and many others. Lol
And guess what ?? in 1936 there's no Jamaican sprinter. So we should not taking his achievements seriously because that time was the prehistoric age of tracks Athletic because the Jamaican weren't there. If we all thinking this way then we will discredit all the achievements in the past.
what a shame
julianng liked this post
08-11-2012, 03:34 PM #42
The tournament prestige is unquestionable but the standards back then were even more undeniably low.
Had other countries have access to good coach, training and playing philosophy, these players will never be so dominant.
The present and the OPEN era is different and more exciting than the past.
08-11-2012, 03:44 PM #43
They were the best and most dominant during their time. This is a great achievement no matter what changes we seen in badminton today.
Maybe their racquets were very heavy and many people did not have access to badminton facility that time. But the fact that Rudy Hartono, Swie King, E. Chong, Frost were all able to get past all these obstacles that prevent from proper facility training etc. and set a new standard for badminton is a great achievement if you ask me. To be honest, maybe if LD was born during that time, the conditions were not favourable for him since the racquets too heavy, no electricity to practice during the night time, or not many courts available in his area etc. etc.... maybe LD couldn't even get into the national team because of these problems our past heroes faced. So their achievement stands as the greatest during their time no matter how different badminton is today.
drquick liked this post
08-11-2012, 04:27 PM #44
Then we can start to questioning the biggest succes of the CHN team that clean sweep all the tittles in this olympic and all they achievements in WC, TC, UC, SC and everything else. They can do all of these because there's no challange from the others strong nation like American, South American, African and rest. Because for now we could say that the only countries that have access of the good coach, training and playing philosophy beside China are Malaysia, Denmark, Indonesia, Japan, Korea, Thailand, Taipei and maybe India. Then we should bring all the things you said above and ensure that every single country, each of all could access that things, and only after that anyone who could win deserve his succes without any doubt. And this should done with every single sport in the world.
We also should put doubt with the succes of Brazillian with Pele in football 3 times WC in 58, 62 & 70. Cuban succes and dominant in Olympic boxing. All achievements in any sports from the past. All for the same reason.
08-11-2012, 08:38 PM #45
I no expert in badminton but I'm pretty sure during rudy time, not many people has the opportunity to play badminton. Most people busy looking for food and shelter. Those who can afford to play badminton are usually from above average rich family.
08-12-2012, 03:42 AM #46
Rudy Hartono is just lucky not to play against the Chinese players, have so few opponents who could actually beat him and to name a few it's not very difficult:
Liem Swie King
No offense to those who lost to Hartono.
When the Chinese came into the scene, he finally lost in his first ever official encounter to a Chinese, Luan Jin.
That puts very much doubt in his "greatness". Also Erland Kops perhaps out of sour grapes, did mention Rudy Hartono broke his record of 7 All England titles with assistance from his Indonesian compatriots (Liem Swie King). This reminds me of Lin Dan's achievements being bashed by fanatics in the present day.
PS: I will find that source where Erland Kops said it and post it as citation.
08-12-2012, 04:52 AM #47
So with the way you think about the past game then we should doubt all the greats player from the past in any discipline of sports for the same reason. Lack of competitors and etc.
In previous post you said about access to good coach, training and playing philosophy but in the last post you said about no financial aid or access to good facilities.
For the Chinesse player like Hou Jiachang and Tang Xianhu, it is very sad that they could not compete in the All England and others IBF tournaments at the time, but undoubtly they are greats players too that BWF included their names in the Badminton Hall of Fame. But it shouldn't be an excuse to doubt Rudy's achievements for that reason.
About his winning against Liem Swie King in his last tittles in 1976, yes there's controversy out there. In his autobiograpy King said that he play very poorly that when he go back to Indonesia his club owner (PB DJARUM) Budi Hartono got mad on him because he thought that King has a very good chance to win the tittles. Although King not revealed was there anyone order him to loose. Still many believe that there was an order in this match to made Rudy become the record holder all time for MS in All England. But again this controversy should not put doubt at Rudy's achievements.
AS for Lin Dan I also doesn't agree with opinion that his achievements is helped by his compratiots. I post it in your thread : Taufik Hidayat's Attitude and Opinion about the All England (#108)
08-12-2012, 04:58 AM #48
Till today, I am sure people still wonder whether did Hartono win that World Championship genuinely because he played against a compatriot. That said, I could say the same for Zhang Ning as well.
08-12-2012, 05:17 AM #49
08-12-2012, 05:19 AM #50
08-13-2012, 10:03 AM #51
Last edited by Fortune; 08-13-2012 at 10:17 AM.
By Bbn in forum Professional PlayersReplies: 22: 01-10-2007, 06:27 PM
By Bbn in forum Professional PlayersReplies: 15: 06-05-2004, 07:23 AM
By Bbn in forum General ForumReplies: 5: 03-27-2004, 08:38 PM
By LIPlayer in forum General ForumReplies: 2: 12-25-2002, 12:19 AM
By Jen in forum General ForumReplies: 6: 04-23-2002, 08:30 PM