Results 2,398 to 2,414 of 3172
Thread: Indonesia Badminton
11-29-2011, 06:26 AM #2398
Irfan/Weni is also average pair, i think. I think both are still not really good.
Jenna/Komala, i think they will get split soon. Nothing special on Komala. Not sure if Komala will still in pelatnas next year.
11-30-2011, 08:46 AM #2399
The INA WS is really getting from bad to worse in terms of performance.
I don't think we can send ANY to GPG level tourneys at this moment. For a start, please let them get exposed to victories at IC level tourneys (like Bella). Then, send them to GP and GPG levels. For SS, send them maybe only to the home event (INA SSP).
These are the tourneys that PBSI can send the first-team players (YES...the first team!) to next year:
Feb - Iran Fajr IC
Mar - Ciputra Hanoi Vietnam IC
Apr - Osaka IC
Jun - Indonesia SSP (home event)
Jul - Indonesia IC (possibly?)
Aug - Yonex-Sunrise Vietnam Open GP
Sep - Yonex Chinese-Taipei GPG (for those with high-enough rankings), Bankkaltim INA GPG (home event)
Nov - Bahrain IC (possibly?), Malaysia IC (possibly?)
Dec - India IC, India GPG
That itself is already 12 tourneys, which is more than enough for them to build up their rankings.
The message is: start from scratch and work your way up from there!
11-30-2011, 09:45 AM #2400
Let's list down the records of the INA WS Players in Pelatnas and compare them to the records of Fransiska Ratnasari of PB Djarum:
Bellaetrix Manuputty 10-5
Best Performance: Winner at Malaysia IC & SF at INA GPG
First-round (and qualifying) exits: 3/6
Hera Desi 11-7
Best Performance: Runner-Up at Malaysia IC
First-round (and qualifying) exits: 3/7
Lindaweni Fanetri 8-14
Best Performance: QF at Indonesia SSP
First-round (and qualifying) exits: 9/14
Adriyanti Firdasari 10-13
Best Performance: QF at Indonesia SSP
First-round (and qualifying) exits: 7/11
Aprilia Yuswandari 7-15
Best Performance: QF at Malaysia GPG
First round (and qualifying) exits: 9/15 tourneys
Maria Febe Kusumastuti 4-12
Best Performance: R16 at Japan SS
First round (and qualifying) exits: 8/12 tourneys
Fransiska Ratnasari 16-7
Best Performance: Winner at Russian IC
First-round (and qualifying) exits: 2/8
What a huge difference! NONE of the Pelatnas first-team players has an even record.
The result also clearly shows why Maria Febe Kusumastuti will probably be returned to PB Djarum next year! Her result this year simply does not make the cut! At the same time, it also JUSTIFIES why Hera Desi & Bellaetrix Manuputty deserve to be promoted to the First-Team!
As for Aprilia Yuswandari vs Lindaweni Fanetri, I will say keep Lindaweni for one more year as she's younger than April and she's the highest ranked Pelatnas player! I will also suggest keeping Firda for one more year as she's the second-highest ranked Pelatnas player at the moment at no 40. Either Linda or Firda has a chance of making it to the London Olympics. And, they have to compete against Fransiska Ratnasari for the sole spot!
So, in total, I will suggest only for the Pelatnas main team to keep 4 players. Plus at most 2 as the second-team (including the WJC 2011 runner-up Elyzabeth Purwaningtyas)
11-30-2011, 12:33 PM #2401
nice analysis badMania
it is a pity to see Febe performance....
she has a good skill and a good footwork actually...
last year, she can play very well against ratchanok inthanon....
dont know why, this year she has a down period....
return to Djarum is the best for her....
11-30-2011, 03:43 PM #2402
I totally agree to badMania's argument.
The WS departement need to build their perfomances from IC level of tourney.
11-30-2011, 06:12 PM #2403
Looking at the draw in WS next week, Maria Febe Kusumastuti will possibly face Han Li in the first round. Adriyanti Firdasari and Bellaetrix Manuputty are also unlikely to beat Liu Xin  and Jiang Yanjiao  respectively. Three first-round casualties are on the card.
As for the rest, Lindaweni Fanetri (if she has recovered)  and Hera Desi are scheduled to meet each other in R16. The winner is likely to face Bae Youn Joo  in the QF.
Finally, even if Aprilia Yuswandari can beat Tee Jing Yee in R32, she's unlikely to beat Sung Ji Hyun  in R16.
12-01-2011, 04:00 AM #2404
by the way, where is Rani Mundiasti now. is she a coach?
last time I know her name is in the late 2008, when she and Jo Novita play in Japan Open.
12-03-2011, 11:45 AM #2405
Olympic is coming shortly.
I think only Tantowi/Lilyana have chance for medal.
As for Simon, the best that he can reach might be QF. He can go as far as SF and go for Bronze if drawing at his side.
The next that can go relatively far is Bona/Ahsan, but they might stop at QF.
Too bad that Kido/Hendra may not qualify if they continue their form. They might have chance for medal.
As for the other, no chance at all.
So, it is likely that INA's Olympic gold medal tradition may end by 2012
12-06-2011, 02:40 AM #2406
Olympic gold medalist calls for better recruitment
Agnes Winarti, The Jakarta Post, Jakarta | Fri, 12/02/2011 7:55 AM
The 1992 Barcelona Olympics gold medalist Susy Susanti urged the Indonesian Badminton Association (PBSI) to recruit more young shuttlers to give them enough time to mature to world-class levels.
“The younger the talent we recruit to the national training camps, the better, said Susy, who joined the PBSI national training camp in Cipayung when she was 15.
“Ideally, they are recruited at age 15, so that there will be some three to four years for them to be molded,” said the four-time All England champion.
Susy also mentioned her successor, “Miracle Girl” Mia Audina, who began training at 14. Mia won Olympic silver medals in Athens and Atlanta.
“In my experience, recruiting talent by the time they are 18 is just a little too late because they are more difficult to mold and direct, both in terms of their mind-set and technique,” said the 40-year-old mother of three.
The 1993 World Champion pointed out Thailand’s achievements in developing young shuttlers, as seen in their current three-time world junior champion Ratchanok Intanon, who is 16.
Improving how the PBSI runs its talent-scouting program is neccessary, Susy added, saying that the talent did not always need to be those who won every tournament.
“Sharp observation and planned talent-scouting is crucial. We can see from their drive, motivation, attitude, technique, intelligence and posture,” she said.
However, the PBSI has their own explanation.
“We never put an age limit on recruitment, actually. But Susy and Mia were exceptional cases,” PBSI head of athletic development Hadi Nasri told The Jakarta Post on Thursday.
“Our main sources of talent are the clubs, and we have been urging them to produce younger talent, but we have not yet found much young talent already displaying the exceptional quality as Susy and Mia did,” Hadi said, citing the youngest shuttlers currently in the national camp were 18-year-olds Tiara Rosalia Nuraidah and Suci Rizki Andini, who play in the women’s doubles.
Susy criticized the singles and doubles specialization as a waste of talent.
“In the old days, even the adult shuttlers played in the singles and doubles. Applying specialization since a junior age is just a waste of talent. Once they can’t perform in their specialty, they will be sacked.”
“Playing in two or three sectors at once is a natural way to strengthen the players’ physique and to learn to keep focus for every match. The more often they play matches, they will also get used to the pressure, both from opponents and spectators,” Susy said, recalling how, during her golden years, she played women’s singles, women’s doubles and mixed doubles.
“When I was a junior, I played up to six matches a day because the semifinals and the finals were held on the same day. I won in all three sectors. It was an effective way of training for me, although I passed out the next day,” Susy said with a laugh.
Susy also highlighted the importance staying injury-free, as it has been an issue among Indonesia’s ace shuttlers such as Greysia Polii, Adriyanti Firdasari and Sony Dwi Kuncoro.
“Regretfully, some of our national shuttlers since they were juniors have been hampered by injuries. Training sessions, for example, must be customized to the needs of each athlete,” Susy said, expressing her concern for 2008 Beijing Olympic bronze medalist Maria Kristin, whose performance afterward was clouded by years of injuries.
“Injury harms both the shuttler’s skills and mind. It is the homework for athletes and coaches to prevent injuries from happening,” Susy said.
With the upcoming 2012 London Olympics, where Indonesia hopes to emulate the golden glory that was pioneered in 1992 by Susy and her husband, Alan Budikusuma, Susy encouraged the country’s shuttlers to arm themselves with strong wills.
“Tontowi Ahmad and Liliyana Natsir in the mixed doubles as well as Bona Septano and M. Ahsan in the men’s doubles both have great chances, but they need to work extra hard within the remaining six months. They have to realize that this opportunity will never come twice. Everything is up to them,” said Susy.
“Back then, in 1992, Alan was not top seeded; it was Ardy [B. Wiranata] who was mandated [by the PBSI] to win the gold. But Alan won the gold. I hope that story can inspire our current shuttlers, despite many who may have doubted [their ability].”
12-07-2011, 02:55 AM #2407
Tantowi/Lilyana chance is not that big as well, but judging by current performances of all PBSI Squads, only they that has highest possibility of continuing INA Gold tradition at badminton.
MK/HS simply haven't found the right tune on their performance.
If they are able to beat CY/FHF & LYD/JJS by London OG 2012, they deserve a chance.
Bona/Ahsan, performance wise, still below those top MD.
12-15-2011, 05:39 AM #2408
Letting the players go to the SS Finals with no coach??? What are PBSI thinking???
12-15-2011, 05:54 AM #2409
I wonder korea md also without their main coach..
12-18-2011, 05:43 PM #2410
For the purpose of discussion, let me repost my response to Hau-Ge's comments (including his original comments) in this thread.
Originally Posted by huangkwokhau
INA's system is different......if we keep changing players...even now..There is strong rumour that Djarum and Jaya Raya may not give their players to Pelatnas ( except XD) as they felt that many of their players were not given chance or being split and being kicked out later....it is a bit complex...
Let me ask you if the winner of Kejurnas has to be IN in Cipayung..do you think Senatria deserves to be part of pelatnas as he has not performed well before( had been demoted)....or Ocoy which has been criticized for not performing ...did not do well in Kejurnas or any tournaments..Li Mao wanted to kick her out...but being Runner UP..she is given a chance as other officials argue that INA WS junior has not been in any podium in WJC......now we all know that it is tough for Ocoy to perform well in future...will you kick her out and give her another chance?
I heard Djarum is worried that later on their players might be kicked out if they dont perform well in first 2 years..so I heard they prefer to groom their own players from now on..also Djarum may not pass their WD and MD players to Pelatnas next year .....thats more complex that you think....
PBSI wanted to demote many players especially in MS and WS but Li Mao thinks some of their players may be performing late....now there is BIG battles between PBSI and Li Mao which believes some of MS juniors are good...and need time under his guidance...
1. To one extent, I do agree that players should be given enough time AND ENOUGH TOURNAMENT EXPOSURE once they are in Pelatnas to see whether they can make the cut. The second part is something that is probably not given enough to ALL the players in Pelatnas (esp the so-called Pratama players). I prefer to see PBSI giving them at least 10 tourneys a year and then check their progress after a year to see if they meet certain target ranking.
For players like Rendy/Afiat and Rijal/Debby, they have been around for about 2 years at least (correct me if I am wrong) but their rankings still cannot go up to the top 20! Rijal/Debby were given 10 tourneys last year and 16 tourneys this year! Sadly, they NEVER REACH the Final and are still at WR21! For Rendy/Afiat, they were given 8 tourneys last year and 12 tourneys (plus the Summer Universiade) this year. Again, their best result is a SF finish and they are still at WR36. Should we give more time to them???
But then, for players like Mohd Ulinnuha/Berry Angriawan, who were actually progressing well last year despite participating in 5 tourneys, they at least won the Indonesia IC 2010 and reached SF in Malaysia IC 2010. Yet, they were split up last year and ended up performing even worse than the original partnership this year.
So, to a certain extent, I like the idea of Djarum and Jaya Raya actually grooming their own players. For example: Praveen Jordan/Didit Juang Indrianto, who are certainly not going to enter Pelatnas, I actually like them and I do think they have some potential as we can see their results in Sirnas in the Open Division this year with a SF finish in most tourneys despite their young age!
2. As I mentioned in the other thread, Elyzabeth Purwaningtyas deserves at least 1 more year in Pelatnas as she at least show that she can win the WJC runner-up medal this year. It's fair....good performance deserves to be rewarded. If she cannot fulfill a specific target by end of next year, then, by all means, kick ker out.
3. Like I said, I actually like the idea. Going to Pelatnas may not be the best idea for some players. In particular, this applies quite a lot to Djarum doubles players like Jenna Gozali, Mohd Ulinnuha, Berry Angriawan, etc, whom I think perform better when they were in Djarum as compared to Pelatnas.
4. I also agree that once you are out, you can no longer enter Pelatnas again. The same applies for Tommy Sugiarto and Alamsyah Yunus, whom I think it's better for them to remain outside Pelatnas and at the same time also achieving good results.
While I agree that the problem is complex, I think it could be solved if PBSI can write a contract with the players whenever they first enter Pelatnas. Specify what are the targets that THEY SHOULD ACHIEVE within the first 2 years, but also tell them how many tourneys they will be sent to (preferably at least 10 and according to their level). Then, evaluate their performance after 2 years and decide accordingly. At the moment, there is no clear performance-based evaluation system that is applied to all players (including the first-team players) and that's why some of them underachieve, whereas the newer players are left wondering whether they are really better off to be in Pelatnas.
12-20-2011, 06:42 AM #2411
Pertamina delivers Rp 2b in support to PBSI
The Jakarta Post | Mon, 12/19/2011 9:54 AM
JAKARTA: State oil company Pertamina has given an additional Rp 2 billion (US$219,000) to support the Indonesian Badminton Association (PBSI) for further development of the sport in the country.
Pertamina, which has served as a so-called “foster parent” to Indonesian badminton since preparation began for the recent 26th Southeast Asian Games (SEA Games), hoped that Indonesian shuttlers would maintain their spirit and continue to work hard to regain the nation’s achievements demonstrated within the sport during the 1990s and early 2000s.
“Indonesia has a potential future in badminton, but recently we have not performed well enough. It requires strong desire to reach achievement,” Pertamina president director Karen Agustiawan said while extending support to the sports federation in Jakarta on Sunday.
As foster parent, Pertamina had previously donated Rp 2 billion to support the SEA Games preparations.
PBSI chief Joko Santoso appreciated Pertamina’s consistent assistance after the Games. “We will make an assessment over the use of all financial support. We have four posts of expenses, which are sending shuttlers to matches overseas, sending coaches and referees to various training sessions, health-related needs, as well as organizing regular training, including hiring motivators,” Joko told reporters.
Joko said that the association could spend up to Rp 40 billion a month when it needs to send athletes to overseas tournaments.
PBSI thus far sees Yonex and Djarum as its main sponsors.
source : http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2...port-pbsi.html
Last edited by miksss; 12-20-2011 at 06:54 AM.
12-20-2011, 08:26 AM #2412
12-20-2011, 08:29 AM #2413
FYI,,,not easy just to split the players as you know...Rendy wanted to split from Afiat but who can become his better partner right now? not now....so he ahs to wait until next year probably.....
Also only so far Djarum and Jaya Raya/Mutiara can afford to groom their players and have financial back up to do so...other clubs cant do that...
PBSI is trying to change the contract for players next year..less but more with bonus to keep them motivated...
Again...in Richard's eyes, Rizal/Debby are still better....
Please remember that China is calling back their players now as they do n ot have many stocks as we think...Recently Wang xin and now Han Li....and China still retains Lu Yi, Zhou Wen Long.etc...even China did not just kick their players out...there is something we need to consider...
Zheng Bo got kicked out, not because of his results..but rather for his behaviours.....
As I said before...it is abit complex..not because PBSI can not kick them out but there is a concern from the coaches who think they may bloom late...and clubs who supplies the players to Cipayung may have a say as well....even there is a guidelines...PBSI does write the contract but in some cases.PBSI fails also to fulfill its obligations to players...so not fair just to kick them out...
12-20-2011, 08:32 AM #2414
source : http://bataviase.co.id/node/913869
The summary only : This year,PB PBSI budgeted cost of Rp 40 billion for operations,including sending athletes overseas.The amount is actually not ideal for preparation for the Olympics.Consequently,PB PBSI should cut the number of young athletes are dispatched to tournaments abroad.Funds are used to dispatch more likely to athletes who won Olympic points.
For the needs of next year,PBSI received an injection of fund Rp 2 billion from PT Pertamina.PB PBSI Chairman Djoko Santoso,said the fund will be allocated to various needs, ranging from sending athletes to health monitoring.
Last edited by miksss; 12-20-2011 at 08:35 AM.
By icon03 in forum Coaching ForumReplies: 2: 02-02-2011, 08:55 AM
By Loh in forum Indonesia Professional PlayersReplies: 56: 06-23-2009, 08:25 AM
By alonzo in forum Chit-ChatReplies: 0: 05-19-2008, 10:21 PM
By elepin in forum Chit-ChatReplies: 0: 08-31-2005, 12:19 AM
By Mag in forum General ForumReplies: 1: 08-28-2002, 08:16 PM