View Poll Results: Releasing the draw on the eve of a badminton tournament
- 133. You may not vote on this poll
It's a good idea
04-05-2008, 02:37 AM #1
Releasing the draw on the eve of a Badminton tournament
I have just received this news released today, Saturday 5-April-2008:
Releasing the draw on the eve of a Badminton tournament
Perhaps, our members here at Badminton Central can vote on this practice suggested by the Badminton World Federation (BWF).
Poll: Releasing the draw on the eve of a Badminton tournament:
(1) Vote for it
(2) Vote against it
Below is the article saying that BWF is wishing to try it.
====== ====== start article ====== ======
Saturday April 5, 2008
Badminton: A first for ABC meet
By Rajes Paul
PETALING JAYA: For the first time ever, shuttlers competing in the Asian Badminton Championships (ABC) will not know who their opponents are until the eve of the tournament.
This is because the draw for the ABC meet, scheduled to be held from April 15-20 in Johor Baru, will only be conducted during the team managers' meeting on April 14.
The ABC is the last tournament offering Asian players the chance to win Olympic qualifying points.
Yesterday, Badminton Asia Confederation (BAC) chief operating officer (COO) Karen Koh said that they decided to hold the draw a day before the tournament to make it more exciting.
Another reason was to avoid changes and replacements in the draw due to last-minute withdrawals.
“Sometimes, re-draws have to be done because the seeded players withdraw at the eleventh hour. This time, the draw will only be done after the team managers have confirmed their players’ entries,” said Karen. “We are trying this out for the first time in a BAC tournament after the executive council gave us the nod. We also asked the hosts – the BAM (Badminton Association of Malaysia) – and they agreed, saying it was a good idea.”
“The draw will be conducted during the team managers’ meeting and everyone will get to see how it is done. This will leave no room for people to question the validity of the draw.”*
Karen said that this (releasing the draw on the eve of a tournament) could become a permanent practice in the Badminton World Federation’s (BWF) Super Series events if the badminton fraternity welcomed it.
On the entries of the players for the ABC, she said the list would be released today.
“The world's best will be coming to Malaysia to compete in this meet. We are determining the seedings of the players based on the latest world rankings. The BAC will release the full cast tomorrow,” she said.
National No. 1 Lee Chong Wei, who is aiming to regain the title which he last won in 2006, will spearhead Malaysia challenge.
====== ====== end article ====== ======
What do you think and how would you vote?
Perhaps kwun could organise a poll on this issue.
Last edited by chris-ccc; 04-05-2008 at 02:48 AM.
04-05-2008, 05:28 AM #2
Sandy's PAW games is now in jeopardy
Oh, I've forgotten to mention how I would vote.
Yes, I would vote for it...... that is, to hold the draw a day before the tournament. It should be more fun and more exciting to hold the draw a day before the tournament when all the players, coaches and team managers are there in attendance.
But for members@Badminton Central playing our Sandy's PAW games, it would be chaotic I suppose.
So sorry that Sandy's PAW games is now in jeopardy.
04-05-2008, 07:53 AM #3
I vote for a "yes..i think it's a good idea.."=)
04-05-2008, 08:18 AM #4
I just commented ...I discussed this with one of BWF official regarding making draw at the eve last year for SS.
Instead of placing Q1 vs Player...it is better to draw on the spot after getting all qualifiers like Tennis.
The issue with BWF is that many players who under RESERVE may not go to the tournament as they do not know who will withdraw from Main and qualifying as well..
I suggested that if there are more players withdraw then we will have Lucky Losers..just like in Tennis...especially for last minute withdrawal.
Then he mentioned that another problem for players or their federations is getting visas as well as booking the ticket and find out later that he/she could not play...
Thats the issues...any suggestion to solve it?
04-05-2008, 08:21 AM #5
Same here. A yes on this one. More exciting and less issue related to players faling out because of different reasons. Makes the tournament go much more smoothly.
Huang's right... new issues popping up.
Last edited by Fengwei; 04-05-2008 at 08:25 AM.
04-05-2008, 10:32 AM #6
This is definitely not a good excuse for a poor planning and execution. As we have seen in many Asian tournaments (GP India is a very obvious one), Asian organisers need to learn a lot from their Europe counterpart.
Till now, we still do not have the list of players for Asian Championship published, while Euro has finalized the draw.
Even smaller tournament like Polish & Finnish Open can do much better than them.
Asia is the powerhouse in the game, but a sloppy organizer in general. That contribute to the lower status of Badminton compared to Tennis.
Just my 2 cents.
04-05-2008, 10:37 AM #7
Only injury is the legitimate excuse once the association has decided to send a player.
We've heard of players not being able to get visas but really, let's face it, that's really poor preparation by the team manager or the team coach confirming entries very late.
04-05-2008, 10:46 AM #8
Visa for UK alone costs INA players Rp 4 million rupiahs or US$ 370 per person.
04-05-2008, 10:51 AM #9
in tennis, you take your chances...if you get into qualifying alone...it may pay off your expenses..it will work well if the prize money is getting bigger and bigger..
I think it will benefit more to the host...becasue if main /qualifying players can not play then reserve from hosts more likely will fill in....
Thats my 10 cents..hehe
Last edited by huangkwokhau; 04-05-2008 at 10:54 AM.
04-05-2008, 11:06 AM #10
In PAW WTA (when I run it for 4 years), Drawing held mostly in Friday for Qualifying and Saturday for Main Draw. Qualifying started to play in Saturday and 1st round started from Monday.
It wasn't a big problem for PAW and I vote Yes
04-05-2008, 12:05 PM #11
I voted " YES" but I think we need to make the rules clearer...I still love the concept though
04-05-2008, 12:10 PM #12
Perhaps it is harder to organise tournaments in Asia
Correct me if I am wrong, but I found that there are more players withdrawing from Asian tournaments at the last moment compared to from European tournaments.
It must be because there are more Asians playing in Asia than in Europe. Asian players are known for withdrawing at the last moment.
Perhaps it is because of this that it is harder to organise tournaments in Asia.
04-05-2008, 12:25 PM #13
04-05-2008, 12:42 PM #14
yup, i agree it's worth a try. as long as the draw is done fairly, which i'm sure it will be, then nobody should have any complaints.
04-05-2008, 04:48 PM #15
Good idea. It defintely has more advantages than disadvantages.
(+) It avoids or minimises redraws. For instance, some players choose to withdraw after receiving a unfavorable draw if the draw is done much earlier.
(+) It ensures more balanced quarters caused by last minute withdrawal by seeded players.
(+) It guarantees certain degrees of suprises in terms of draw.
(-) Baddy enthusiats have to wait longer before the draw is released.
Just my 2 cents...
04-05-2008, 05:36 PM #16
The Poll Results after the first 20 votes
The Poll Result after the first 14 hours (20 votes);
It's a good idea...... 80.00%
Not welcomed....... 20.00%
04-05-2008, 07:49 PM #17
Welcomed for big events like Super Series and Worlds and Olympics but other than that not welcomed, maybe not even for Super Series. Big federations can probably afford to take the risk but smaller ones surely can't.
By Miqilin7 in forum China Professional PlayersReplies: 5: 04-12-2012, 07:37 PM
By bad-vancouver in forum Badminton VancouverReplies: 2: 10-09-2011, 08:35 PM
By anjoooo in forum Australia / New ZealandReplies: 4: 09-30-2008, 11:01 PM
By madbad in forum RichmondPro Badminton CentreReplies: 2: 04-10-2007, 08:35 PM
By Jenny in forum General ForumReplies: 0: 09-19-2001, 05:08 AM