Results 1 to 17 of 22
09-18-2008, 09:20 AM #1
Racket suggestion for small girl, small boy & teenager
Q1) What racket would you suggest for a girl (8-9yrs old), height: 1.24m, small build, starting badminton 1st time? Please give brand, model, specification & reasoning or experiences
Q2) What racket would you suggest for a boy (10-11yrs old), height:1.40m, small build, fast feet, good coordination & can play generally? Please give brand, model, specification & reasoning or experiences
Q3) What racket would you suggest for a boy (12-15yrs old), height: 1.5 - 1.8m, average build,strong shoulder, general coordination is alright, footwork a bit slow, energetic & can play? Please give brand,model, specification & reasoning or experiences.
Q4) What racket would you suggest for a girl (12-17 yrs old), height: 1.4-1.8m, average build, generall coordination is just alright, footwork slow, not as energetic but can play? Please give brand, model, specification & reasoning or experiences.
Thank you in anticipation of a lively suggestion
Maybe as the contribution get bigger, someone with capable IT knowledge may want to gather the recommendation with future update opportunity as new model emerge.
I would like to ask the same on shoes too but not sure this is the right place to post.
09-18-2008, 05:07 PM #2
Are these people trying to play serious or just for fun?
09-19-2008, 01:12 AM #3
I would suggest anyone who's above 10 and under the height of 1.40m to use basic series or isometric as they are just starting badminton and they are mostly practicing movements and all the basic theories (I'm just making assumptions). Those who are under 10 should consider playing with Junior series racquets (short racquet for increase movement of racquet, and less weight for faster body movement).
Those who have experience with badminton, can play generally well, and know their style of playing, I would think Muscle Power 45 (for defensive), Carbonex 30 Muscle (for balanced style), and Armortec 700 (for offensive and heavy smashers) are your selection of racquets from Yonex.
This is solely personal opinions and I've only had past experience with these racquets.
Note: Different people with different body structures handles racquets differently. Best bet is to let them try/demo racquets and allow them to select the one that suits them the most. Also, as you play more, you gain experience and your style may interchange.
Thanks, hope it helps!~
PS: I'm very strict on children using expensive racquets, so I tend to keep the budget as low as possible and not compromising their badminton experience. Also, Victor produces very nice racquets. You may ask Victor experts too~
Last edited by Gemcat; 09-19-2008 at 01:15 AM.
09-19-2008, 03:05 AM #4
Let say it is not for fun.
It will be difficult to say whether it is serious or not but
if their parents drove to the gym, to drop them for the junior session and they turn up two weeks in a roll, my guess I can consider them serious.
With children as youg as 9yrs old, they could change their mind too.
In anycase, what rackets would be suitable if a child who turn up and hope to play.
I think the budget consideration should be taken into account.
Some parents are willing to spend on a "good" racket for their child but obviously, we do not wish them to spent on a pro end Yonex and it would not have make any differences on their playing or coaching. "Good" not necessary expensive or latest.
Assu ming we can suggest two categories
B) Racket that can last & improve
When you mentioned Isometric series, which model would you suggest? why?
What recommendation on:
A) Budget end
B) Reasonably serious
C) Those who are serious enough to want improvement
09-19-2008, 03:19 AM #5
If you are looking at Yonex then any low end MP racket is fine. You can also buy 2 apacs rackets on ebay for ~$60USD.
09-19-2008, 05:16 AM #6
Where I play, many parents take their children to play with them. I've seen kids between 5-8 playing with normal lenght rackets -- and it is obviously no problem for them. Junior rackets are for kids under 5 -- that's what I think.
Buy several different rackets and make these children try each of them -- they will find what they like best.
09-19-2008, 05:45 AM #7
Thanks for the feedback, which Apacs rackets would you suggest? Any reasons?
I think some of the adult(normal) length rackets maybe too long for the younger or smaller kids, as Gemcat suggested, the short/junior version would be appropraite. Once they are bigger, they can also be rewarded with an adult size racket (great for encouragement and inspire them to achive the next level)
In tennis, they have 23inches, 25 & 26 before the 27 or 27.5 inches of the adult size.
Obviously in tennis weight is also a factor.
What about Badminton?
I am inviting suggestions so we might be able to point parents in the right direction or range & let them decide themselves.
As from the coach/teaching point of view, any coaches can give guidance?
09-19-2008, 06:25 AM #8
Short rackets are pointless!
Because they are the same weight, but... shorter
With normal lenght rackets these kids will be able to do more. Not smashes ofcourse, but better clears and drops. It is simple physics. They will reach more, have more power and so on...
And a normal racket will not harm or injur them (see the beginning of this post), or affect their movement. There is nothing wrong with normal lenght rackets for grown-up shilds (8 and more years old).
About the new racket being a motivation -- NO! NO! NO! It should not be a motivation to play badminton....
09-20-2008, 01:12 PM #9
Sorry for the slow reply.
The Isometric I have played with is the Isometric 24 VF. Since the racquet is in the lower-end of the line, the weight is 2U (90-94.9g). This racquet is made out of graphite so it's not as heavy as other steel racquets. However, compared with other higher-end ones, this racquet is very heavy. Note that the Isometric should be mainly used for starters to practice. If they (either starters or junior) want to participate in a game, I suggest they switch to Carbonex 8000 Light because the shoulder and arm joints will sore if they were to use Iso 24 VF.
The number of racquets to be purchased is dependant on your need and number of students under you.
09-20-2008, 04:52 PM #10
Gemcat, Thanks for the suggestion.
I think your suggestion is genuine and very practical & yet do not break the bank
To start training etc, we can suggest the 24VF to my group Q3 & Q4
Maybe even Q2
In fact Q3 &Q4 may even go better
Quantities will depend on number of children & budget.
I am hoping for suggestion to list out the range of suitable racket so the parents can decide for themselves
I do not agree with your 2nd point, Even when you watch programme where they teach parents how to control difficult children, they use a simple tactic, REWARD when it is good & administer punish for bad behaviour (Not necessary heavy punishment)
Even when training animals, you practice the same principle.
In the adult world, we use "Bonus" or "Promotion"
They will have something to look forward to and a reward of a new racket(adult) is only a small reward because they grow and you will probably have to give them a racket somewhere along the line.
I can understand your point that the weight probably do not differ much between a short racket & adult racket.
It is my group Q1 and maybe Q2 are the my concern. Should I recommend a short racket to start off with.
I would like feedback from others, maybe coaches & parents etc.
How about other brand rackets recommendation?
09-20-2008, 05:42 PM #11
Go with a full length racket. I know a kid thats about 4 feet tall, and uses a full length.
09-20-2008, 06:04 PM #12
Don't go with short rackets because they are made out of metal so that means it weighs just the same as a full length racket that is graphite.
09-21-2008, 04:30 AM #13
I think if the kids are able to cope with a full size racket, we should recommend one too, that is why Group Q3 & Q4 is very much a full size racket but any suggestion of made, model & reason?
It is the younger ones which we are considering at the moment.
You see them holding a full size racket & you know something is not quite right or balance
it could be
a) Due to the length is too long. When serving, they hit the floor 1st before it hit teh shuttles or when swung it always hit the floor because the racket is too long
b) the weight might have hindered their movement. It could be the racket is too heavy for the girl body, frame shoulder or arm. she can't lift the racket high because it is to off balance/heavy or can't swing back or swing the racket properly
You know what I mean? seems to hold the racket down and in backhand position.
Why do you ask on another thread 11yrs old girl what type of racket she prefer? head light etc?
Does that ahve any bearing in the 4 groups here?
which Apacs rackets would you suggest for each of the 4 groups
09-21-2008, 11:48 AM #14
For girl you should get her something that is bit heavier, but she can move around and probably a head light racket.
09-22-2008, 02:45 AM #15For girl you should get her something that is bit heavier, but she can move around and probably a head light racket.
Did I misunderstood, why a bit heavier?
Why headlight too?
Or your rteasoning, please
09-22-2008, 09:41 AM #16
Am just saying a racket that she can handle, a bit heavy but she can still use. To devolve the muscles in her forearm, for drives and lifts and stuff like that.
09-26-2008, 10:33 AM #17
Head light racket means easier to move the racket around so the arms do not get tired easily, right?
Head heavy racket tends to be good for Smasher or atatcking player (my understanding) so presumably headlight is good for general playinclusive lifting, serving hitting for a less strong person.
What about balance racket, what or how it contribute to the player?
What would be a good weight for a girl to start off with?
To all, what racket did you first start off with and why you discard it or what you like? Share those experiences with us.
ps Will a racket too light, difficult to generate power in hitting?
By wyemarn in forum Broken RacketsReplies: 10: 09-11-2011, 08:10 AM
By louis_tan in forum Buy & Sell - Read the rules sticky before you postReplies: 3: 01-27-2010, 12:04 PM
By Kelvin in forum Chit-ChatReplies: 13: 04-16-2009, 04:10 PM
By GunBlade008 in forum Racket Recommendation / ComparisonReplies: 13: 11-21-2006, 08:39 PM
By xofrevlis in forum Badminton Rackets / EquipmentReplies: 19: 02-14-2004, 12:15 AM