Team List for the SCG Thomas Cup Preliminaries Round 2010
- Thread starter badMania
- Start date
justme_manda
Regular Member
Thailand's Top players will not be playing in the Thomas Cup. They will be represented by a young team.
phaichamnan
Regular Member
The conclusion of Thai Professional Conflict
Today conclusion about Thai badminton professional that resign from BAT is
They will play only Sea Games and Asian Games but not under BAT
Today conclusion about Thai badminton professional that resign from BAT is
They will play only Sea Games and Asian Games but not under BAT
ctjcad
Regular Member
Thanks for the tidbit..
But hope they'll make up their absences somehow, someway, in those 2 future tourneys.
..sorry to hear THA's top players won't compete. Really too bad; chances are they won't make it to the Final Rd. in M'sia.
But hope they'll make up their absences somehow, someway, in those 2 future tourneys.
btw guys..those top THA players who quit already on the list and registered by BAT..
if we take a look at the regulation "Each competing Member Associations shall nominate not fewer than four (4) players and not more than ten (10) players. Only nominated players shall be permitted to play as selected players or substitutes"
so how can BAT change those withdrawn players with other youngsters ??
this is the source http://www.badmintonasia.org/event_details.aspx?eventID=212
if we take a look at the regulation "Each competing Member Associations shall nominate not fewer than four (4) players and not more than ten (10) players. Only nominated players shall be permitted to play as selected players or substitutes"
so how can BAT change those withdrawn players with other youngsters ??
this is the source http://www.badmintonasia.org/event_details.aspx?eventID=212
THA TC 1 PONSANA BOONSAK
2 SAENSOMBOONSUK TANONGSAK
3 VILAILAK PAKKAWAT
4 AVIHINGSANON SUPPANYU
5 PRAPAKAMOL SUDKET
6 ANUGRITAYAWON SONGPHON
7 NARKTHONG NUTTAPHON
8 CHALARDCHALAEM PATIPHAT
9 JONGJIT MANEEPONG
10 ISARA BODIN
UB
1 PONSANA SALAKJIT
2 BURANAPRASERTSUK PORNTIP
3 TAERATTANACHAI SAPSIREE
4 INTANON RATCHANOK
5 JINDAPOL NITCHAON
6 VORAVICHITCHAIKUL KUNCHALA
7 AROONKESORN DUANGANONG
8 AMITRAPAI SAVITREE
9 MUNKIT VACHARAPORN
10 THOUNGTHONGKAM SARALEE
guys, which are those players withdrawn ? -most of them-
those are the registered players for TCUC prelims..so..refer to the regulation (my post above) how can BAT change the players ?
2 SAENSOMBOONSUK TANONGSAK
3 VILAILAK PAKKAWAT
4 AVIHINGSANON SUPPANYU
5 PRAPAKAMOL SUDKET
6 ANUGRITAYAWON SONGPHON
7 NARKTHONG NUTTAPHON
8 CHALARDCHALAEM PATIPHAT
9 JONGJIT MANEEPONG
10 ISARA BODIN
UB
1 PONSANA SALAKJIT
2 BURANAPRASERTSUK PORNTIP
3 TAERATTANACHAI SAPSIREE
4 INTANON RATCHANOK
5 JINDAPOL NITCHAON
6 VORAVICHITCHAIKUL KUNCHALA
7 AROONKESORN DUANGANONG
8 AMITRAPAI SAVITREE
9 MUNKIT VACHARAPORN
10 THOUNGTHONGKAM SARALEE
guys, which are those players withdrawn ? -most of them-
those are the registered players for TCUC prelims..so..refer to the regulation (my post above) how can BAT change the players ?
simonlovers
Regular Member
Thomas Cup
Group A - Indonesia, Vietnam, Singapore
Group B - Taipei, Hongkong, Philippines
Group C - India, Thailand, Srilanka, Cambodia
Group D - Japan, Korea, Laos
Uber Cup
Group X - Korea, Indonesia, Thailand, Singapore, Srilanka
Group Y - Japan, Hongkong, Taipei, India, Philippines
Group A - Indonesia, Vietnam, Singapore
Group B - Taipei, Hongkong, Philippines
Group C - India, Thailand, Srilanka, Cambodia
Group D - Japan, Korea, Laos
Uber Cup
Group X - Korea, Indonesia, Thailand, Singapore, Srilanka
Group Y - Japan, Hongkong, Taipei, India, Philippines
simonlovers
Regular Member
TC: group D: japan, korea, laos >>> hell
what if korea as the top of the group ?? japan may not qualify cos there will be 3 countries (must be 3 of the top of the groups) and 1 lucky loser must be one of the top of the group...
UC: group Y is tougher than X
top 2 countries each group will go to semifinal.
quite obvious from group X will be Korea and Indonesia...(not to mention thailand coz their top women already withdrawn)
nahhh..group Y i dont have any idea, it could be japan+hongkong or japan+taipe or hongkong+taipe...hihihiii
what if korea as the top of the group ?? japan may not qualify cos there will be 3 countries (must be 3 of the top of the groups) and 1 lucky loser must be one of the top of the group...
UC: group Y is tougher than X
top 2 countries each group will go to semifinal.
quite obvious from group X will be Korea and Indonesia...(not to mention thailand coz their top women already withdrawn)
nahhh..group Y i dont have any idea, it could be japan+hongkong or japan+taipe or hongkong+taipe...hihihiii
simonlovers
Regular Member
i dont know about the method of asia preliminaries
if
Thomas Cup - just one team from each group it must be : INA, TPE, IND (if No Boonsak and or Tanongsak) and KOR(points from PSH and 2 MD)
Uber Cup - just two team from each group
X - KOR, INA(if no Salakjit)
Y - JPN, HKG/TPE
finally it ended with win win
from the news i follow up, it now end the president of TBA agreed with coachs and players proposal.
1. TBA postpone the "team contract" with YNX brand.
2. Players are still with their personal brand sponsor.
3. Players practice/ training on their own place and venue.
4. TBA to allow player to be in selection for national team event e.g. TH, UB, Asiangame, OLY, etc.
5. Open event, Superseries to be endorsed by TBA for participate by the players with their own sponsoer/ personal expenses.
I believe the top players be in this upcoming TH, UB cup venue.
from the news i follow up, it now end the president of TBA agreed with coachs and players proposal.
1. TBA postpone the "team contract" with YNX brand.
2. Players are still with their personal brand sponsor.
3. Players practice/ training on their own place and venue.
4. TBA to allow player to be in selection for national team event e.g. TH, UB, Asiangame, OLY, etc.
5. Open event, Superseries to be endorsed by TBA for participate by the players with their own sponsoer/ personal expenses.
I believe the top players be in this upcoming TH, UB cup venue.
simonlovers
Regular Member
Ups....
THA top players join this prelilminaries..
thomas
Group winner : INA, TPE, THA (IND may suprise), KOR
uber
X - KOR, INA (THA may suprise, INA MUST secure 2 WD,50:50 for all WS)
Y - JPN, HKG (TPE may suprise, but HKG will secure 3 WS)
THA top players join this prelilminaries..
thomas
Group winner : INA, TPE, THA (IND may suprise), KOR
uber
X - KOR, INA (THA may suprise, INA MUST secure 2 WD,50:50 for all WS)
Y - JPN, HKG (TPE may suprise, but HKG will secure 3 WS)
http://www.nationmultimedia.com/2010/02/11/sport/sport_30122297.php
Yeah, looks like the top players would play at least for the qualifying round.
Yeah, looks like the top players would play at least for the qualifying round.
justme_manda
Regular Member
BAT chief accepts players' demands
Boonsak Ponsana, right, and Sompol Kukasemkit tell the Senate committee on sports about their conflict with the badminton chiefs on Monday. THITI WANNAMONTHA
But the conflict seems far from over as a representative of the players and coaches claimed the BAT's move was "insincere."
Sports Authority of Thailand (SAT) governor Kanokphand Chulakasem yesterday held a talk with BAT president Charoen Wattanasin to find a way to solve the problem.
Charouck Arirachakaran, secretary-general of the National Olympic Committee of Thailand (NOCT), was present as a witness.
The closed-door meeting was called after 12 players, led by Boonsak Ponsana, and four coaches, led by Sompol Kukasemkit and Udom Luangphetcharaporn, announced last week that they were quitting the national team to protest the BAT's mismanagement.
They said they could not accept the BAT's attempt to sign a "team contract" with a sporting goods manufacturer and demanded certain BAT executives including Charoen resign.
After yesterday's meeting, Kanokphand announced that the problem was over as Charoen accepted some of the players and coaches' conditions.
Charoen agreed that the players can train at any venue other than BAT's courts, that they are still eligible to represent the country, that the BAT will endorse them to play in tournaments and that the controversial team contract is put on hold.
Charoen said he had done his best to end the conflict. "It's about different views. I have tried to stay as calm as I can," he said.
He said he welcomed the players and coaches to return to the national side for the Thomas Cup and Uber Cup preliminary rounds in Nakhon Ratchasima next week.
But Udom said Charoen's move would not eradicate the root of the problem.
"It is not yet over. They just want the leading players to play in the Thomas Cup and Uber Cup. They ignored the cause of the problem," said Udom, who coaches Boonsak.
He said all the players were not fit physically and mentally for the tournament.
"We have not trained since Jan 24 and Boonsak is nursing an injury," he said. "We will look into the details and make a decision about our next move."
Boonsak is suffering from a swollen ankle now after spraining his ankle during a football match last week. Doubt he will start training anytime soon. From what I was being told, the players will most likely not participate for TC and UC.
- Published: 11/02/2010 at 12:00 AM
But the conflict seems far from over as a representative of the players and coaches claimed the BAT's move was "insincere."
Sports Authority of Thailand (SAT) governor Kanokphand Chulakasem yesterday held a talk with BAT president Charoen Wattanasin to find a way to solve the problem.
Charouck Arirachakaran, secretary-general of the National Olympic Committee of Thailand (NOCT), was present as a witness.
The closed-door meeting was called after 12 players, led by Boonsak Ponsana, and four coaches, led by Sompol Kukasemkit and Udom Luangphetcharaporn, announced last week that they were quitting the national team to protest the BAT's mismanagement.
They said they could not accept the BAT's attempt to sign a "team contract" with a sporting goods manufacturer and demanded certain BAT executives including Charoen resign.
After yesterday's meeting, Kanokphand announced that the problem was over as Charoen accepted some of the players and coaches' conditions.
Charoen agreed that the players can train at any venue other than BAT's courts, that they are still eligible to represent the country, that the BAT will endorse them to play in tournaments and that the controversial team contract is put on hold.
Charoen said he had done his best to end the conflict. "It's about different views. I have tried to stay as calm as I can," he said.
He said he welcomed the players and coaches to return to the national side for the Thomas Cup and Uber Cup preliminary rounds in Nakhon Ratchasima next week.
But Udom said Charoen's move would not eradicate the root of the problem.
"It is not yet over. They just want the leading players to play in the Thomas Cup and Uber Cup. They ignored the cause of the problem," said Udom, who coaches Boonsak.
He said all the players were not fit physically and mentally for the tournament.
"We have not trained since Jan 24 and Boonsak is nursing an injury," he said. "We will look into the details and make a decision about our next move."
Boonsak is suffering from a swollen ankle now after spraining his ankle during a football match last week. Doubt he will start training anytime soon. From what I was being told, the players will most likely not participate for TC and UC.
Last edited: