Hitting a duff shuttle out during a rally to claim a let?

T

tubby

Regular Member
During a match last week an opponent hit a shuttle out of court and tried to claim a let.

What happened was during a rally the shuttle really deteriorated and became almost impossible to play. My opponent hit it sideways out of his side of the court i.e. trying to make a statement that he was not hitting it over the net and wanted to play a let because the shuttle had got so bad. Neither side really had an advantage in the rally at that point.

It may sound harsh, but I refused the let. I didnt think there was any basis for a let. Both sides were disadvantaged with the poor shuttle and the shuttle should only be changed between points.

If it was a club night then maybe this could be allowed, but i had never seen this before and it was a league match.

Was I too harsh?
 
The rules only allow a let if the base separates from the shuttle.
I wouldn't have given a let.

(were the opponents from a club that normally play with plastics? They tend to get the most annoyed about feather deterioration. But then we do moan about their crappy plastic shuttles when we have to play at their place...)
 
it's rules from BWF that the shuttle must remain in play not matter how crap the quality is unless the cork separates from the feathers. so even if it's flattened and flying like a rocket, you can't end the rally and play a let
 
the rules say, even if the shuttle is breaking apart you must finish the rally, unless the shuttle spoils during the rally, you cannot stop halfway and claim anything
 
tubby said:
Was I too harsh?
Click to expand...

Well I can totally see what everyone means and they are right but I think if that was me I would probably play a let just to keep the peace and not create a bad atmosphere.

Can I ask what the score was and to who at the time and also final score?:)
 
Stealthboy said:
Well I can totally see what everyone means and they are right but I think if that was me I would probably play a let just to keep the peace and not create a bad atmosphere.
Click to expand...

Imagine you unjustifiably play a let and your side loses the match. So you consider keeping peace with your opponents who you would play maybe twice a year more important than keeping peace with your own club mates for the rest of the year ?
 
You can't claim a 'let'. It's against the rules. It's not a matter of politeness:) However, the opposing side might not know.

Or they might know but want to change the shuttle in which case it should have been done before the start of the rally. Alternatively. wait until after the rally.
 
Being polite is one thing, follow the proper rule is another. You can be as nice as possible, but if no one follows the rule or even abuse the rule, what's the point for the game then?

So, I can simply hit everything out, and each time provide a reason like, too slow, too fast, too heavy, too light, too whatever... :(
 
Ive had a similar incident where the opposition player destroyed a perfect shuttle after the second rally of the game hit the shuttle off the court and replaced the shuttle.

It was blatant shuttle tampering.
 
Stealthboy said:
Can I ask what the score was and to who at the time and also final score?:)
Click to expand...

I cant remeber what the score was, but it was close.

I know what you said about keeping the peace, but it could have an impact if I had felt that they had got away with it. I refused the let, put it out of my mind and I was able to focus on the rest of the game.

If I had allowed the let then I might have dwelt on it which could have had an impact on my game.

Now I know what is the the right thing to do within the rules of the game.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top